Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Friday, November 11, 2011
Sometimes You're Out Of Control
Finally, when it comes to character freedom of action, no discussion on the use of the mind would be complete without something being said on mind control, which has a long and traditional history of use in both RPGs and fiction.
To start with, in D&D, we have items, monsters and spells that all enable the DM to control the player's actions. A party will never hesitate to use spells or potions and the like against monsters, and we all love to turn the monsters against themselves. In kind, a party encountering a magic user, a nixie or siren, among a wide host of other monsters, expects to suffer a bit from the charm spell. It isn't always pleasant, but there are plenty of opportunties for a DM to step in and tell the player characters what they have to do, because they been charmed, or suggested, or magic jarred, or what have you.
It isn't as though the whole mind control technique hasn't been employed for centuries to keep things interesting. Merlin being enchanted by Vivien. The fun and games of A Midsummer Night's Dream. Mina Harker from Dracula. The Emperor Ming from Flash Gordon. Heinlein's The Puppet Masters. McCoy and Sulu in Return of the Archons. The Penguin. The Imperius curse.
Over and over again, characters get overwhelmed by the dark, unforgiveable influence of the evil forces at work in the world. It isn't fun, but now and then you don't get to say what happens to your character ... and them's the breaks.
A DM, obviously, has to be very careful how this kind of scenario is played out. He or she can't simply rope a party by having a magician show up and turn everyone into mindless zombies. No, first a tale has to be told, which includes words like 'danger' and 'curse,' and preferably has some reference to the tendency of the evil entity/device to control the minds of people in contact with it.
Then, preferably, the party should have to willingly travel overland towards where the entity/device is, thus willingly making the choice to either ignore, or intelligently challenge the entity/device in its lair.
If, however, the lair is approached, and if the party has gotten there of their own free will, then the DM is fair to judge that Pandora's Box has indeed been opened. It's no use trying to stuff all the bad back into the box. It is too late. The DM is at that point perfectly justified in turning the party into zombies.
My personal feeling is, however, that the DM is also responsible for offering the party a way out. There has to be an end game that neutralizes the effect ... and fairly quickly, since otherwise the campaign is going to get awful frustrating and boring.
Mind control in a campaign is a difficult adventure to run. It involves trust - mostly, the players trusting that the DM isn't going to just fuck around with them for fun. Given the general behavior of a great many DMs, this is a very difficult trust to earn. Parties are notably gun shy. And that's why I say, be sure the party recognizes their part in making the mind control happen, and get them out as quick as you can.
And while the adventure is happening, tell your party to sit back and enjoy the ride as much as they can, with their hands inside the car, until the 'coaster comes to a complete stop.
To start with, in D&D, we have items, monsters and spells that all enable the DM to control the player's actions. A party will never hesitate to use spells or potions and the like against monsters, and we all love to turn the monsters against themselves. In kind, a party encountering a magic user, a nixie or siren, among a wide host of other monsters, expects to suffer a bit from the charm spell. It isn't always pleasant, but there are plenty of opportunties for a DM to step in and tell the player characters what they have to do, because they been charmed, or suggested, or magic jarred, or what have you.
It isn't as though the whole mind control technique hasn't been employed for centuries to keep things interesting. Merlin being enchanted by Vivien. The fun and games of A Midsummer Night's Dream. Mina Harker from Dracula. The Emperor Ming from Flash Gordon. Heinlein's The Puppet Masters. McCoy and Sulu in Return of the Archons. The Penguin. The Imperius curse.
Over and over again, characters get overwhelmed by the dark, unforgiveable influence of the evil forces at work in the world. It isn't fun, but now and then you don't get to say what happens to your character ... and them's the breaks.
A DM, obviously, has to be very careful how this kind of scenario is played out. He or she can't simply rope a party by having a magician show up and turn everyone into mindless zombies. No, first a tale has to be told, which includes words like 'danger' and 'curse,' and preferably has some reference to the tendency of the evil entity/device to control the minds of people in contact with it.
Then, preferably, the party should have to willingly travel overland towards where the entity/device is, thus willingly making the choice to either ignore, or intelligently challenge the entity/device in its lair.
If, however, the lair is approached, and if the party has gotten there of their own free will, then the DM is fair to judge that Pandora's Box has indeed been opened. It's no use trying to stuff all the bad back into the box. It is too late. The DM is at that point perfectly justified in turning the party into zombies.
My personal feeling is, however, that the DM is also responsible for offering the party a way out. There has to be an end game that neutralizes the effect ... and fairly quickly, since otherwise the campaign is going to get awful frustrating and boring.
Mind control in a campaign is a difficult adventure to run. It involves trust - mostly, the players trusting that the DM isn't going to just fuck around with them for fun. Given the general behavior of a great many DMs, this is a very difficult trust to earn. Parties are notably gun shy. And that's why I say, be sure the party recognizes their part in making the mind control happen, and get them out as quick as you can.
And while the adventure is happening, tell your party to sit back and enjoy the ride as much as they can, with their hands inside the car, until the 'coaster comes to a complete stop.
Thursday, November 10, 2011
Anti-Strategy
Let me ask if you have never made an error in judgment. Obviously, you have. We all have. We date people we really should not date, and we ignore the warnings of our friends and trusted family members in order to date those people. We even get married when we shouldn't. We take jobs we know are going to be bad news, and we quit jobs in the heat of the moment, only afterwards to realize what a stupid thing that is to do. We skip completing assignments or procrastinate about them, only to find ourselves in the worst sort of place when these things become due and we're pulled up on the carpet to answer for what a crappy job we've done.
Why do we act this way? We know it is not in our best interest. Yes, its true that we want sex, or we need the money, or that the game is on or the crew is going to the bar tonight and working on a task means missing all that. But we also know that we should listen to our friends. We know we should do our jobs. We know that without money, we're fucked. So why can't we simply have the wisdom to tell the difference between what is important, and what is REALLY important?
I don't pretend to answer that. I do want to point out, however, that we are NOT always aware of what is best for us, and we do NOT always do things in our own best interests. We are at the mercies of our hormones, our comprehension of how boring the responsible action will be, or what we perceive we might be missing by acting smartly. We are not perfect. We are human beings.
But if you want to get a real fight going at a D&D table, propose that a player can't do something because their wisdom says their character is not capable of thinking the way they themselves are.
Players - and power players especially - are used to treating D&D as a strategy game like chess. No one would ever suggest you couldn't move your king's pawn to king 4 because the king's pawn has a wisdom of 9 and isn't feeling up to that right now. You don't have to roll against intelligence to find out if the king's horse can jump a pawn and leap to king's bishop 3. These things are simply not part of the game. It is a strategy game, not a wishy-washy bunch of crap about 'feelings' or interpersonal limitations ... so let's not have any of that crap in D&D.
Arguably, it might have been a mistake to incorporate wisdom, intelligence, or even charisma into a game that was bound to be played almost universally by strategists. If I am going to give credit to Gygax for any given thing, it is going to be the genius of incorporating a limitation into the game that would well and truly fuck strategists FOR EVER. Not that the strategists pay any attention, of course. They simply ignore the stats (unless something strategic is derived from them), and players with a 10 wisdom character play precisely the way that players with an 18 wisdom character do. Want to argue with the king? No problem. Don't want to sleep with the girl? Of course you don't have to. Get up and fight although you only have one hit point and you can't win - don't think about it. OF COURSE your 8 wisdom character wouldn't refuse. This is a strategy game, after all.
Except that it isn't, obviously. But still after forty years the word has not come down. People have no trouble not being able to do something because they're not strong enough. The limitations of our bodies are not OUR limitations. Or so we fool ourselves into believing.
A player in my online campaign recently said, regarding failing a wisdom check, "I'm just not used to not having control of my character for non-magical reasons." But of course he is. We all are. We make rolls all the time to determine if we can do something, and when we can't, we're used to not having that control. We would have preferred the die went our way, but ... oh well.
The point here is that we're not used to not having control of our character's thought processes ... because this is pure anathema to our sensibilities. We can take failing at a task. It is murderously hard to take failing at a task because we're not smart enough.
That is why we associate so many of the things at the start of this post with shame and guilt, and things we'd rather never talk about again. Moreover, RPGs are a way of living a life without shame, or guilt. We kill without guilt. We steal without guilt. We conquer the world without guilt. We're unashamed, loud, self-important bastards, bellowing at the bartenders and barmaids of the world without worry or concern for anyone's feelings, in particular our own.
And who the hell wants any of that emotional baggage in a D&D game?
Well, frankly, I do. Because it's real. It's the substance and source of what makes us who we are. Even the difficult bits where we fail at what we wish we were able to do. Our failings are a thousand times more interesting than our successes, and they make our successes wonderful. I'm not going to sacrifice that whole potential aspect of the game, which is what makes this game better and more important than chess.
My players are not chesspieces. They're alive.
Why do we act this way? We know it is not in our best interest. Yes, its true that we want sex, or we need the money, or that the game is on or the crew is going to the bar tonight and working on a task means missing all that. But we also know that we should listen to our friends. We know we should do our jobs. We know that without money, we're fucked. So why can't we simply have the wisdom to tell the difference between what is important, and what is REALLY important?
I don't pretend to answer that. I do want to point out, however, that we are NOT always aware of what is best for us, and we do NOT always do things in our own best interests. We are at the mercies of our hormones, our comprehension of how boring the responsible action will be, or what we perceive we might be missing by acting smartly. We are not perfect. We are human beings.
But if you want to get a real fight going at a D&D table, propose that a player can't do something because their wisdom says their character is not capable of thinking the way they themselves are.
Players - and power players especially - are used to treating D&D as a strategy game like chess. No one would ever suggest you couldn't move your king's pawn to king 4 because the king's pawn has a wisdom of 9 and isn't feeling up to that right now. You don't have to roll against intelligence to find out if the king's horse can jump a pawn and leap to king's bishop 3. These things are simply not part of the game. It is a strategy game, not a wishy-washy bunch of crap about 'feelings' or interpersonal limitations ... so let's not have any of that crap in D&D.
Arguably, it might have been a mistake to incorporate wisdom, intelligence, or even charisma into a game that was bound to be played almost universally by strategists. If I am going to give credit to Gygax for any given thing, it is going to be the genius of incorporating a limitation into the game that would well and truly fuck strategists FOR EVER. Not that the strategists pay any attention, of course. They simply ignore the stats (unless something strategic is derived from them), and players with a 10 wisdom character play precisely the way that players with an 18 wisdom character do. Want to argue with the king? No problem. Don't want to sleep with the girl? Of course you don't have to. Get up and fight although you only have one hit point and you can't win - don't think about it. OF COURSE your 8 wisdom character wouldn't refuse. This is a strategy game, after all.
Except that it isn't, obviously. But still after forty years the word has not come down. People have no trouble not being able to do something because they're not strong enough. The limitations of our bodies are not OUR limitations. Or so we fool ourselves into believing.
A player in my online campaign recently said, regarding failing a wisdom check, "I'm just not used to not having control of my character for non-magical reasons." But of course he is. We all are. We make rolls all the time to determine if we can do something, and when we can't, we're used to not having that control. We would have preferred the die went our way, but ... oh well.
The point here is that we're not used to not having control of our character's thought processes ... because this is pure anathema to our sensibilities. We can take failing at a task. It is murderously hard to take failing at a task because we're not smart enough.
That is why we associate so many of the things at the start of this post with shame and guilt, and things we'd rather never talk about again. Moreover, RPGs are a way of living a life without shame, or guilt. We kill without guilt. We steal without guilt. We conquer the world without guilt. We're unashamed, loud, self-important bastards, bellowing at the bartenders and barmaids of the world without worry or concern for anyone's feelings, in particular our own.
And who the hell wants any of that emotional baggage in a D&D game?
Well, frankly, I do. Because it's real. It's the substance and source of what makes us who we are. Even the difficult bits where we fail at what we wish we were able to do. Our failings are a thousand times more interesting than our successes, and they make our successes wonderful. I'm not going to sacrifice that whole potential aspect of the game, which is what makes this game better and more important than chess.
My players are not chesspieces. They're alive.
Wednesday, November 9, 2011
More Intelligence: Back To Technology
Would that I had a little time to get a post written today. Oh wait, here it is.
Whatever the conclusions that came out of yesterday's post, with my proposing for all of ninety minutes the possibility of rewriting the combat tables and then rescinding them, I still find myself in the same basic quandary: How does a low intelligence differ from a high intelligence in principles of game play?
Granting for the time being (the next thirty years or so) that the effect isn't upon combat, what exactly is effected? Roleplay?
Okay, I've taken a few moments to stop laughing and get myself together. No, obviously not roleplay. No two people in RPGs can agree on any rule binding roleplay for three minutes at a time.
Frankly, I'm not concerned with whether intelligence 'conforms to scientific reality' or not. I just want a game system that is defined, clear, practical and allows for extrapolations to be made in world design and game play.
Consider, if the gentle reader will, that the lower orders of intelligence are fairly well defined. A zero-intelligence denotes no thought at all. A one-intelligence permits the conception of most animals ... with an instinctual thought structure based on seek food or flee.
Two-intelligence brings the lesser sort of animal hunters who, while associating in tribes, tend to attack singly or in not-so-organized groups (the lions bringing down an elephant in David Attenborough's Planet series is a good example). You can see it here.
A three-intelligence describes a small step up, not so much in terms of combat strategies, but more so as regards personal inter-relationships, such as among the lower apes.
The four-intelligence, or "semi-intelligent" by D&D standards, excellently describes the higher ape. So in that we have the brink of tool using culture ... where tools are used, but not specifically fabricated for use. This is a question of intelligence, since while you can teach an ape to use a specific tool, you can't teach it to understand how the tool works, or indeed expect it to understand why the tool is superior. It learns to use the tool by rote, and not by reason.
Logically, then, the five-intelligence or better creature steps into the realm of primitive tool fabrication and proper tribal organization. "Low" intelligence, so-called.
At this point I think I would have to argue against considering the matter one of intelligence at all. Simply throw out that appellation at this point, and define any intelligence higher than 4 as a question of technology, which can be separated. In effect, a 5 intelligence merely describes a 10 intelligence creature hundreds of thousands of years lacking in social and cultural development. We can leave any other discussion of intelligence on the shelf, so to speak, and simply not speak of it.
Once we do that, we can easily make a definition between a "low-intelligence culture" and a "human culture." Humans use metal tools. Humans have developed religion. Humans read & write. Humans have access to theoretical science. Lower cultures do not.
If you like, you can consider in a medieval setting that it wasn't easy for more advanced cultures, like Europe, to have a steady impact on less advanced cultures, like that of the Bantu or the Nentsis of the Arctic shore. Some jerk is going to rush at this point to bark about how the Bantu were actually very advanced, but this is a relative question. Does "very advanced" mean they knew how to grow food and pick sores from their bodies, or does "very advanced" mean the development of a printing press and subsequent literature. People have a tendency to ascribe the phrase "very advanced" to a wide variety of things.
An 'intelligence' scale (remember we put actual intelligence upon a shelf), balanced against a group of technologies, such as those to be found in, say, Civilization IV, which I've spent a lot of time writing about, might solve the whole problem. Certain technologies could be allocated to certain 'intelligence' ratings on a point system ... so that if a creature had a 7 intelligence, you could define just exactly what technologies that creature possessed and which it did not ... with the added benefit that two seven-intelligence cultures need not have the exact same technological advances.
Just throwing it out there.
Whatever the conclusions that came out of yesterday's post, with my proposing for all of ninety minutes the possibility of rewriting the combat tables and then rescinding them, I still find myself in the same basic quandary: How does a low intelligence differ from a high intelligence in principles of game play?
Granting for the time being (the next thirty years or so) that the effect isn't upon combat, what exactly is effected? Roleplay?
Okay, I've taken a few moments to stop laughing and get myself together. No, obviously not roleplay. No two people in RPGs can agree on any rule binding roleplay for three minutes at a time.
Frankly, I'm not concerned with whether intelligence 'conforms to scientific reality' or not. I just want a game system that is defined, clear, practical and allows for extrapolations to be made in world design and game play.
Consider, if the gentle reader will, that the lower orders of intelligence are fairly well defined. A zero-intelligence denotes no thought at all. A one-intelligence permits the conception of most animals ... with an instinctual thought structure based on seek food or flee.
Two-intelligence brings the lesser sort of animal hunters who, while associating in tribes, tend to attack singly or in not-so-organized groups (the lions bringing down an elephant in David Attenborough's Planet series is a good example). You can see it here.
A three-intelligence describes a small step up, not so much in terms of combat strategies, but more so as regards personal inter-relationships, such as among the lower apes.
The four-intelligence, or "semi-intelligent" by D&D standards, excellently describes the higher ape. So in that we have the brink of tool using culture ... where tools are used, but not specifically fabricated for use. This is a question of intelligence, since while you can teach an ape to use a specific tool, you can't teach it to understand how the tool works, or indeed expect it to understand why the tool is superior. It learns to use the tool by rote, and not by reason.
Logically, then, the five-intelligence or better creature steps into the realm of primitive tool fabrication and proper tribal organization. "Low" intelligence, so-called.
At this point I think I would have to argue against considering the matter one of intelligence at all. Simply throw out that appellation at this point, and define any intelligence higher than 4 as a question of technology, which can be separated. In effect, a 5 intelligence merely describes a 10 intelligence creature hundreds of thousands of years lacking in social and cultural development. We can leave any other discussion of intelligence on the shelf, so to speak, and simply not speak of it.
Once we do that, we can easily make a definition between a "low-intelligence culture" and a "human culture." Humans use metal tools. Humans have developed religion. Humans read & write. Humans have access to theoretical science. Lower cultures do not.
If you like, you can consider in a medieval setting that it wasn't easy for more advanced cultures, like Europe, to have a steady impact on less advanced cultures, like that of the Bantu or the Nentsis of the Arctic shore. Some jerk is going to rush at this point to bark about how the Bantu were actually very advanced, but this is a relative question. Does "very advanced" mean they knew how to grow food and pick sores from their bodies, or does "very advanced" mean the development of a printing press and subsequent literature. People have a tendency to ascribe the phrase "very advanced" to a wide variety of things.
An 'intelligence' scale (remember we put actual intelligence upon a shelf), balanced against a group of technologies, such as those to be found in, say, Civilization IV, which I've spent a lot of time writing about, might solve the whole problem. Certain technologies could be allocated to certain 'intelligence' ratings on a point system ... so that if a creature had a 7 intelligence, you could define just exactly what technologies that creature possessed and which it did not ... with the added benefit that two seven-intelligence cultures need not have the exact same technological advances.
Just throwing it out there.
Tuesday, November 8, 2011
Rethinking Intelligence
For a bit I'd like to write a bit about the intelligence of various humanoid races, without getting bogged down in the particulars of this race or that, but rather to concentrate upon the difference between what is a "low" intelligence and what is a "high" intelligence ... to get a handle on the various intelligence levels and what they might mean.
I don't suppose for a moment that Gygax and crew had any more idea of the differences between 'very intelligent' and 'extraordinarily intelligent' than do the people playing the game right now. They were convenient labels, they sounded like they were stacked in a logical order, and it was obviously presupposed that people would just esoterically accept the labels without any need for them to be defined. And indeed, they are not defined. What, for example, can a very intelligent creature NOT do that a highly intelligent creature can? Is it even a question of ability? Is it the speed at which a creature can think? And if so, how does that affect the game in any way?
There aren't any rules for it, so we know Gygax was pulling the whole framework out of his ass, or phoning it in if you prefer, dumping it into the book and then moving onto things that were scaled and made sense. I know a lot of players out there don't think its important, or don't care, but like any scientist I want those things scaled and measured and clearly understood as to what a 13 intelligence means as opposed to a 12 intelligence. I'm not satisfied with rolling the difference out, since intelligence is in fact not random. People with higher intelligence DO understand things intuitively that people with lower intelligence do not ... to the eternal chagrin of persons with lower intelligence.
Measuring understanding is, however, a very difficult science, and hasn't been understood yet with regards to actual intelligence ... and therefore it would be difficult to hang game rules on any study of the subject. Alas, we are limited in creating game rules to things that can be established in black and white terms: a 6 on a d6 is not a 5, cannot be mistaken for a five, and never will be a 5. This is the sort of game rule we need for intelligence. Not because a very intelligent creature isn't occasionally stupid, or because a stupid creature can't have moments of genius, but because in the wider sense, we are talking of cultural entities comprised of stupid creatures and genius creatures, and therefore there's something to be argued for statistical generalities.
For example: how is a Naga culture profoundly different from a Goblin culture. We know the nagas are smart and the goblins not so much, but what exactly does 'different' mean? How do we resolve what ought to be present in a naga culture? Or in any culture for that matter.
There is, of course, the pulling it out of the DM's ass technique, the tried and true method, forever defended and requiring absolutely no continuity or logic whatsoever. The lovely thing about this method is that it needs no defense, as illogic is in itself a kind of proof. If you are the sort that ballyhoos this method, and do so loudly and proudly, you really shouldn't be reading this post, or this blog for that matter. I'm not your sort of beer buddy. I'm sure your time could be better spent right now buying lottery tickets. Go get one and the rest of us will continue.
Since I can't measure comprehension in any way that is as absolutist as I want for the game, I'm pretty much in the realm of ability vs. non-ability, or knowledge vs. non-knowledge. It's really the realm of wisdom and not intelligence, but we generally suppose from fiction that a really smart culture possesses all sorts of cool and interesting technologies that a really backward culture doesn't have. Note, please, that we don't call them "dumb cultures." There is the presumption, always present, that a backward culture will one day be a forward culture, on the same track that we ourselves followed. In fact, we can thank Star Trek and other sources for hammering into our minds that every primitive culture is filled with people who are just as smart as we are, they just haven't sat in classrooms and been taught jet propulsion and gross anatomy.
There's a physiological precendent for this, of course - that being that we are substantially unchanged from the same biological construct, Cro-magnon man, who roamed the planet 150,000 years ago. We have the same brain, the same structure, the same built-in probable comprehension of languages and so on. We understand from our studies that if we could teleport a Cro-magnon baby from the distant past into our present, it would probably be fully capable of learning language and growing up just as any modern child. There are a lot of reasons to think this is true, but I'm not going to go into them; feel free to do some of your own reading.
So we are not really any 'smarter' than our distant ancestors, which argues that our civilization is just the happenstance of hitting upon technologies which have changed our outlook this way and that. Those technologies came very slowly for the first 140,000 years, but they piled upon each other and eventually led to processes in our culture that taught us how to seek technologies, no longer relying upon discovering them by accident.
An accidental technology would be something like the acquisition of fire. I don't say discovery, of course, because fire was around long before we were ... but at some point we know that the domestication of fire - the power to make fire at will, and not depend on gathering it from a random source - was probably hit upon by witnessing some particular event and reproducing that event. Unlike modern technologies, where we conceive of the technology and then actively bring it about without ever having any prior proof that it was possible to bring it about.
I digress into this because I'd like to step into the realm of humanoid species that were not cro-magnon man ... since we are, after all, talking about goblins and bugbears as opposed to humans. Our one obvious example is Neanderthal man, which had been in existence for some 400,000 years prior to the arrival of Cro-magnon. We have a long cultural history of perceiving that the Neanderthal was dumber than we were. It was supposed for several hundred years that we wiped them out because we were smarter, but it is understood now that we probably intermarried with them and that all of us today possess a fair quantity of Neanderthal genes - arguably, some more than others.
It is not as though Neanderthals were without technologies of their own. Prior to the Cro-magnons appearing, they developed tools, weapons, techniques and cultures all their own. There's no doubt from the evidence that Cro-magnons were superior in these things, but since we already perceive that technology is a result of circumstance and development, and not necessarily intelligence, there is a little proposal to make here.
First, however, let's point out that the speed at which technologies were witnessed and reproduced was certainly much faster with the Cro-magnon species. The Neanderthals had 400,000 years to accomplish what they accomplished, and we managed what we have in only 150,000. So we were obviously more observant and quicker at picking up nature's ball than were the Neanderthals.
But suppose there had never been any Cro-magnons. Suppose that the Neanderthals had another million years or so to pick up the ball, so to speak. It's not an unreasonable proposition. Can we really argue that Neanderthals wouldn't have eventually learned how to be rocket scientists?
Perhaps it would have taken much, much longer. Perhaps Neanderthal universities would require ten or twenty years of steady training to bring Neanderthal children up to scale ... and perhaps Neanderthal doctors would only practice for ten or fifteen years before having to retire. We can presume their lifespans were longer, like ours became longer, but perhaps all the training it took would shorten the professional years of practice.
From this perspective, aren't we saying that a goblin can do as much as a naga, given its time of existence? Perhaps goblins are just 'dumb' because they were only created a few millenia ago, whereas naga have been around for 25,000 years. And perhaps humans aren't quite as smart as a naga, but they've had 125,000 years longer to learn how to do stuff. And as we know, it's those last five hundred years that really make the difference.
Consider that every humanoid race smarter than your average dog is generally considered to have mastered the power of fire. You don't picture a bunch of bugbears sitting around a camp without a fire going, do you? Have you ever described a camp of 'intelligent' creatures at night without a fire? But of course there were such camps, for hundreds of thousands of years, in our own actual history.
This makes the argument that either A) every creature is smart enough to create fire, even if it means they were shown how to do so last week; and B) every creature has had the same amount of time to develop as a race that we have had. Either way, we're looking at a system of homogenous intelligence, where once the technology is created by one culture, it immediately becomes available to all the other cultures because we as DMs don't - or can't - perceive any difference. Goblins may be a little less organized in your combats, but they still use all the same weapons, have the same armor, gather food the same way and sit around the same fires that your much smarter elves sit around. There doesn't seem to be any problem in a goblin or a bugbear being able to manipulate technology once its put into their hands.
What I'm saying is that this is substantially wrong. Using a sword, for instance, is not just a matter of picking it up and swinging it. An ape can do that. Doesn't make the ape a swordsman. Swordplay is a complex intellectual pursuit that requires gauging a lot of factors besides your ability to swing. In other words, you might be able to put a sword in a bugbear's hand, but you shouldn't expect the bugbear to be able to parry with it, or set up combinations, or know about the intricacies of footwork and so on. It is a low intelligence creature. Even if you could teach it over ten years how to do those things, it would NEVER be smart enough to react to something in swordplay it had never seen before. It simply wouldn't have the intelligence to interpret what it was seeing and concoct a logical strategy against it. By the time a low intelligence creature could do all that, it would be dead. Remember, Cro-magnons are three times faster than Neanderthals.
The same ought to be true with creatures in the game who are smarter than us. They ought to be able to fight with swords at a skill level much higher than an ordinary person - or indeed do anything with a much higher ability. Their comprehension should be lightning-quick, the intricacies of their language much harder to grasp, their tools requiring a tasking multiplicity our brain-pans can't perform at the same rate. Oh, sure, you might eventually learn how to play their variety of chess ... but you'll never win if you're playing 'speed-chess' with them. You don't think that fast.
The thrust of all this writing comes down to this:
1) Virtually every technology in the game is equally spread among all races regardless of intelligence, and probably no one wants to change that.
2) Intelligence is speed of comprehension, and not the possession of technologies.
For that matter, intelligence is the possession of certain moralities, but that's another essay.
A smarter creature therefore ought to be able to use all the same existing technologies better ... and that is the scale that ought to be put into place. It shouldn't be that a naga or a bugbear has a better to hit table because it has more hit dice. Both should fight on to hit tables that are commensurate with their intelligence. And the same ought to be true with most die rolls. A smarter fighter should be able to do better with a grapple. He or she should be able to leap from a high place with less likelihood of dying. He or she should be able to take down a bigger, stronger opponent even if that other opponent is a higher 'level' ... which might be a case of a better to hit table for the lower level, smarter fighter and a lot of hit points for the higher level, dumber fighter. And that might be a very interesting - and quite socially common - contest.
Intelligence, not strength or dexterity, ought to be the MASTER stat.
But nobody bothered to make rules for it.
I don't suppose for a moment that Gygax and crew had any more idea of the differences between 'very intelligent' and 'extraordinarily intelligent' than do the people playing the game right now. They were convenient labels, they sounded like they were stacked in a logical order, and it was obviously presupposed that people would just esoterically accept the labels without any need for them to be defined. And indeed, they are not defined. What, for example, can a very intelligent creature NOT do that a highly intelligent creature can? Is it even a question of ability? Is it the speed at which a creature can think? And if so, how does that affect the game in any way?
There aren't any rules for it, so we know Gygax was pulling the whole framework out of his ass, or phoning it in if you prefer, dumping it into the book and then moving onto things that were scaled and made sense. I know a lot of players out there don't think its important, or don't care, but like any scientist I want those things scaled and measured and clearly understood as to what a 13 intelligence means as opposed to a 12 intelligence. I'm not satisfied with rolling the difference out, since intelligence is in fact not random. People with higher intelligence DO understand things intuitively that people with lower intelligence do not ... to the eternal chagrin of persons with lower intelligence.
Measuring understanding is, however, a very difficult science, and hasn't been understood yet with regards to actual intelligence ... and therefore it would be difficult to hang game rules on any study of the subject. Alas, we are limited in creating game rules to things that can be established in black and white terms: a 6 on a d6 is not a 5, cannot be mistaken for a five, and never will be a 5. This is the sort of game rule we need for intelligence. Not because a very intelligent creature isn't occasionally stupid, or because a stupid creature can't have moments of genius, but because in the wider sense, we are talking of cultural entities comprised of stupid creatures and genius creatures, and therefore there's something to be argued for statistical generalities.
For example: how is a Naga culture profoundly different from a Goblin culture. We know the nagas are smart and the goblins not so much, but what exactly does 'different' mean? How do we resolve what ought to be present in a naga culture? Or in any culture for that matter.
There is, of course, the pulling it out of the DM's ass technique, the tried and true method, forever defended and requiring absolutely no continuity or logic whatsoever. The lovely thing about this method is that it needs no defense, as illogic is in itself a kind of proof. If you are the sort that ballyhoos this method, and do so loudly and proudly, you really shouldn't be reading this post, or this blog for that matter. I'm not your sort of beer buddy. I'm sure your time could be better spent right now buying lottery tickets. Go get one and the rest of us will continue.
Since I can't measure comprehension in any way that is as absolutist as I want for the game, I'm pretty much in the realm of ability vs. non-ability, or knowledge vs. non-knowledge. It's really the realm of wisdom and not intelligence, but we generally suppose from fiction that a really smart culture possesses all sorts of cool and interesting technologies that a really backward culture doesn't have. Note, please, that we don't call them "dumb cultures." There is the presumption, always present, that a backward culture will one day be a forward culture, on the same track that we ourselves followed. In fact, we can thank Star Trek and other sources for hammering into our minds that every primitive culture is filled with people who are just as smart as we are, they just haven't sat in classrooms and been taught jet propulsion and gross anatomy.
There's a physiological precendent for this, of course - that being that we are substantially unchanged from the same biological construct, Cro-magnon man, who roamed the planet 150,000 years ago. We have the same brain, the same structure, the same built-in probable comprehension of languages and so on. We understand from our studies that if we could teleport a Cro-magnon baby from the distant past into our present, it would probably be fully capable of learning language and growing up just as any modern child. There are a lot of reasons to think this is true, but I'm not going to go into them; feel free to do some of your own reading.
So we are not really any 'smarter' than our distant ancestors, which argues that our civilization is just the happenstance of hitting upon technologies which have changed our outlook this way and that. Those technologies came very slowly for the first 140,000 years, but they piled upon each other and eventually led to processes in our culture that taught us how to seek technologies, no longer relying upon discovering them by accident.
An accidental technology would be something like the acquisition of fire. I don't say discovery, of course, because fire was around long before we were ... but at some point we know that the domestication of fire - the power to make fire at will, and not depend on gathering it from a random source - was probably hit upon by witnessing some particular event and reproducing that event. Unlike modern technologies, where we conceive of the technology and then actively bring it about without ever having any prior proof that it was possible to bring it about.
I digress into this because I'd like to step into the realm of humanoid species that were not cro-magnon man ... since we are, after all, talking about goblins and bugbears as opposed to humans. Our one obvious example is Neanderthal man, which had been in existence for some 400,000 years prior to the arrival of Cro-magnon. We have a long cultural history of perceiving that the Neanderthal was dumber than we were. It was supposed for several hundred years that we wiped them out because we were smarter, but it is understood now that we probably intermarried with them and that all of us today possess a fair quantity of Neanderthal genes - arguably, some more than others.
It is not as though Neanderthals were without technologies of their own. Prior to the Cro-magnons appearing, they developed tools, weapons, techniques and cultures all their own. There's no doubt from the evidence that Cro-magnons were superior in these things, but since we already perceive that technology is a result of circumstance and development, and not necessarily intelligence, there is a little proposal to make here.
First, however, let's point out that the speed at which technologies were witnessed and reproduced was certainly much faster with the Cro-magnon species. The Neanderthals had 400,000 years to accomplish what they accomplished, and we managed what we have in only 150,000. So we were obviously more observant and quicker at picking up nature's ball than were the Neanderthals.
But suppose there had never been any Cro-magnons. Suppose that the Neanderthals had another million years or so to pick up the ball, so to speak. It's not an unreasonable proposition. Can we really argue that Neanderthals wouldn't have eventually learned how to be rocket scientists?
Perhaps it would have taken much, much longer. Perhaps Neanderthal universities would require ten or twenty years of steady training to bring Neanderthal children up to scale ... and perhaps Neanderthal doctors would only practice for ten or fifteen years before having to retire. We can presume their lifespans were longer, like ours became longer, but perhaps all the training it took would shorten the professional years of practice.
From this perspective, aren't we saying that a goblin can do as much as a naga, given its time of existence? Perhaps goblins are just 'dumb' because they were only created a few millenia ago, whereas naga have been around for 25,000 years. And perhaps humans aren't quite as smart as a naga, but they've had 125,000 years longer to learn how to do stuff. And as we know, it's those last five hundred years that really make the difference.
Consider that every humanoid race smarter than your average dog is generally considered to have mastered the power of fire. You don't picture a bunch of bugbears sitting around a camp without a fire going, do you? Have you ever described a camp of 'intelligent' creatures at night without a fire? But of course there were such camps, for hundreds of thousands of years, in our own actual history.
This makes the argument that either A) every creature is smart enough to create fire, even if it means they were shown how to do so last week; and B) every creature has had the same amount of time to develop as a race that we have had. Either way, we're looking at a system of homogenous intelligence, where once the technology is created by one culture, it immediately becomes available to all the other cultures because we as DMs don't - or can't - perceive any difference. Goblins may be a little less organized in your combats, but they still use all the same weapons, have the same armor, gather food the same way and sit around the same fires that your much smarter elves sit around. There doesn't seem to be any problem in a goblin or a bugbear being able to manipulate technology once its put into their hands.
What I'm saying is that this is substantially wrong. Using a sword, for instance, is not just a matter of picking it up and swinging it. An ape can do that. Doesn't make the ape a swordsman. Swordplay is a complex intellectual pursuit that requires gauging a lot of factors besides your ability to swing. In other words, you might be able to put a sword in a bugbear's hand, but you shouldn't expect the bugbear to be able to parry with it, or set up combinations, or know about the intricacies of footwork and so on. It is a low intelligence creature. Even if you could teach it over ten years how to do those things, it would NEVER be smart enough to react to something in swordplay it had never seen before. It simply wouldn't have the intelligence to interpret what it was seeing and concoct a logical strategy against it. By the time a low intelligence creature could do all that, it would be dead. Remember, Cro-magnons are three times faster than Neanderthals.
The same ought to be true with creatures in the game who are smarter than us. They ought to be able to fight with swords at a skill level much higher than an ordinary person - or indeed do anything with a much higher ability. Their comprehension should be lightning-quick, the intricacies of their language much harder to grasp, their tools requiring a tasking multiplicity our brain-pans can't perform at the same rate. Oh, sure, you might eventually learn how to play their variety of chess ... but you'll never win if you're playing 'speed-chess' with them. You don't think that fast.
The thrust of all this writing comes down to this:
1) Virtually every technology in the game is equally spread among all races regardless of intelligence, and probably no one wants to change that.
2) Intelligence is speed of comprehension, and not the possession of technologies.
For that matter, intelligence is the possession of certain moralities, but that's another essay.
A smarter creature therefore ought to be able to use all the same existing technologies better ... and that is the scale that ought to be put into place. It shouldn't be that a naga or a bugbear has a better to hit table because it has more hit dice. Both should fight on to hit tables that are commensurate with their intelligence. And the same ought to be true with most die rolls. A smarter fighter should be able to do better with a grapple. He or she should be able to leap from a high place with less likelihood of dying. He or she should be able to take down a bigger, stronger opponent even if that other opponent is a higher 'level' ... which might be a case of a better to hit table for the lower level, smarter fighter and a lot of hit points for the higher level, dumber fighter. And that might be a very interesting - and quite socially common - contest.
Intelligence, not strength or dexterity, ought to be the MASTER stat.
But nobody bothered to make rules for it.
Monday, November 7, 2011
Big Enough To Fail
If you have a passing acquaintance with physics, and if you have the least knowledge of biological construction, you know already that giant creatures are flat out impossible, and that if they came into existence at the flick of a wand, they would collapse immediately under the weight of their own flesh.
There is a reason why insects or crustaceans are small, particularly on land. It is the nature of the exoskeleton, in which the structural integrity of the creature comprises an outer shell enveloping the meaty goodness. The bouyancy and pressurization of water will enable larger crustaceans to exist and retain their integrity, but the gentle reader will take note that one does not see four-pound lobsters clambering around, or 20-pound oysters or nestling upon dry land.
It is a simple mathematics problem. If we consider a beetle, for example. It is easy to find an example that might be one centimeter in length, and perhaps a total of one fifth of a cubic centimeter in size. If we suppose that the beetles mass is equal to one fifth of a gram as well, we can compare the beetle's length to its mass as a ratio of 5:1.
If we increase double the length of the beetle, we increase the overall surface of that beetle's shell by the square of that length. The larger beetle's skeleton is now four times larger than before. However, the mass of the body is cubed, and is now eight times larger that it was before. The larger beetle now weighs 1.6 grams. The ratio to its length to mass has changed dramatically, and is now 5:4.
As we continue to double the size of the beetle, the mass increases exponentially while the body size of the beetle increases only arithmetically. In other words, in very short order the beetle hits a size in which it cannot exist. This is why the largest beetles in the world are only 15 centimeters long.
It is no different with creatures with internal structures, like ourselves. If we double the height of a typical 200-lb. human, keeping all things in the same proportions, we find we have a giant that weighs 1,600 lbs ... with a far lesser percentage of that meat directly attached to the bones supporting the weight. Even if we propose that the bones are larger, and that the tendons supporting the muscles and attaching them to the bones are larger, we still find ourselves with massive amounts of flesh and organs which will simply tear free from the structure of the skeleton, reducing our giant a mass of gooey muck.
Now, what I am not saying is that there should be no giant monsters in D&D. Giants, along with huge crabs, ants the size of dogs, hornets the size of Volvos and so on are romantically fascinating things, and the game demands their existence. Rather, I am proposing that there must be some other justification for the presence of these huge versions of smaller, natural creatures. The obvious answer is magic.
We can suppose that there is some sort of 'magical integrity field' that enables the bones of a giant to support its massive size, or a rhinocerous beetle the size of a bus to scurry over the earth despite the comparison of its tiny legs to its necessary weight. Perhaps it is some sort of net, with invisible nodes that extend to each critical support point in the monster's body, sustaining that point and keeping it free of the inexorable pull of gravity. One might imagine having goggles that enable the viewer to see the magical 'tendons' extending throughout the giant creature's body.
Would this not, however, mean that if you chose to detect magic in the direction of a giant scorpion hiding in the bushes, the presence of the scorpion would be revealed? Shouldn't this be true with all such creatures? And if I should choose to dispel magic, shouldn't the body of the cyclops simply collapse, killing the creature? And what other ways might there be to magically affect his integrity field, once we have argued for its existence.
Which creatures would, and would not, have this field? A giant rat is no larger than a small dog. Certainly the reason there are no pig-sized rats in the real world is not because pig-sized creatures can't exist due to the skeletal-to-body mass ratio. So where does one draw the line, exactly. Where does "very large bear" end and "impossibly large bear" begin? When the bear is 1,500 lbs? 1,700 lbs? Do I need my Guinness book of records to tell me when the creature starts being 'magical?'
We could posit that large creatures are 'magical' but that they're a different kind of magical that isn't affected by the existing canon of mage spells. That seems like a bit of a hand wave to me, and in any case begs the question that if this magic integrity field exists, how come mages through the ages haven't researched to find spells that directly effect the field - never mind simply causing damage to the creatures, but rather simply obliterating the creature's ability to keep itself standing upon the earth's gravity well on its spindly little legs?
And while we're on the subject, perhaps the existence of giant creatures isn't regulated by a magical field? What if there's some other reason? I can't think of one and I'm open to suggestions. I know some of you out there will be thinking "smaller gravity well," which has long been the staple of science fiction novels. It won't work. At some point the limit is still met, and mass will still fail to hang off the bone. You've only changed the ratio limit.
The hand wave is the obvious solution. But are we really looking for solutions, or are we looking for new ways to tap into inconsistences that have been hand-waved to the point where we've forgotten a hand wave was necessary? Why shouldn't anti-giant creature magic be in some way be available? "A wizard did it" only preposes that a wizard can undo it.
There is a reason why insects or crustaceans are small, particularly on land. It is the nature of the exoskeleton, in which the structural integrity of the creature comprises an outer shell enveloping the meaty goodness. The bouyancy and pressurization of water will enable larger crustaceans to exist and retain their integrity, but the gentle reader will take note that one does not see four-pound lobsters clambering around, or 20-pound oysters or nestling upon dry land.
It is a simple mathematics problem. If we consider a beetle, for example. It is easy to find an example that might be one centimeter in length, and perhaps a total of one fifth of a cubic centimeter in size. If we suppose that the beetles mass is equal to one fifth of a gram as well, we can compare the beetle's length to its mass as a ratio of 5:1.
If we increase double the length of the beetle, we increase the overall surface of that beetle's shell by the square of that length. The larger beetle's skeleton is now four times larger than before. However, the mass of the body is cubed, and is now eight times larger that it was before. The larger beetle now weighs 1.6 grams. The ratio to its length to mass has changed dramatically, and is now 5:4.
As we continue to double the size of the beetle, the mass increases exponentially while the body size of the beetle increases only arithmetically. In other words, in very short order the beetle hits a size in which it cannot exist. This is why the largest beetles in the world are only 15 centimeters long.
It is no different with creatures with internal structures, like ourselves. If we double the height of a typical 200-lb. human, keeping all things in the same proportions, we find we have a giant that weighs 1,600 lbs ... with a far lesser percentage of that meat directly attached to the bones supporting the weight. Even if we propose that the bones are larger, and that the tendons supporting the muscles and attaching them to the bones are larger, we still find ourselves with massive amounts of flesh and organs which will simply tear free from the structure of the skeleton, reducing our giant a mass of gooey muck.
Now, what I am not saying is that there should be no giant monsters in D&D. Giants, along with huge crabs, ants the size of dogs, hornets the size of Volvos and so on are romantically fascinating things, and the game demands their existence. Rather, I am proposing that there must be some other justification for the presence of these huge versions of smaller, natural creatures. The obvious answer is magic.
We can suppose that there is some sort of 'magical integrity field' that enables the bones of a giant to support its massive size, or a rhinocerous beetle the size of a bus to scurry over the earth despite the comparison of its tiny legs to its necessary weight. Perhaps it is some sort of net, with invisible nodes that extend to each critical support point in the monster's body, sustaining that point and keeping it free of the inexorable pull of gravity. One might imagine having goggles that enable the viewer to see the magical 'tendons' extending throughout the giant creature's body.
Would this not, however, mean that if you chose to detect magic in the direction of a giant scorpion hiding in the bushes, the presence of the scorpion would be revealed? Shouldn't this be true with all such creatures? And if I should choose to dispel magic, shouldn't the body of the cyclops simply collapse, killing the creature? And what other ways might there be to magically affect his integrity field, once we have argued for its existence.
Which creatures would, and would not, have this field? A giant rat is no larger than a small dog. Certainly the reason there are no pig-sized rats in the real world is not because pig-sized creatures can't exist due to the skeletal-to-body mass ratio. So where does one draw the line, exactly. Where does "very large bear" end and "impossibly large bear" begin? When the bear is 1,500 lbs? 1,700 lbs? Do I need my Guinness book of records to tell me when the creature starts being 'magical?'
We could posit that large creatures are 'magical' but that they're a different kind of magical that isn't affected by the existing canon of mage spells. That seems like a bit of a hand wave to me, and in any case begs the question that if this magic integrity field exists, how come mages through the ages haven't researched to find spells that directly effect the field - never mind simply causing damage to the creatures, but rather simply obliterating the creature's ability to keep itself standing upon the earth's gravity well on its spindly little legs?
And while we're on the subject, perhaps the existence of giant creatures isn't regulated by a magical field? What if there's some other reason? I can't think of one and I'm open to suggestions. I know some of you out there will be thinking "smaller gravity well," which has long been the staple of science fiction novels. It won't work. At some point the limit is still met, and mass will still fail to hang off the bone. You've only changed the ratio limit.
The hand wave is the obvious solution. But are we really looking for solutions, or are we looking for new ways to tap into inconsistences that have been hand-waved to the point where we've forgotten a hand wave was necessary? Why shouldn't anti-giant creature magic be in some way be available? "A wizard did it" only preposes that a wizard can undo it.
Friday, November 4, 2011
My It's A Good Day, Isn't It?
I've been remiss this week in not posting here, as my online campaign has been going sensationally, full of intrigue and puzzling events, plus a few moments of raw terror. There's a part of me that thinks if I'm writing here, I'm not answering questions and presenting the next scene there, which seems wrong somehow. For example, I could be carrying forth the campaign right now.
And running D&D is sort of the point of it all, isn't it?
Still, I have a few things on my mind and I thought I'd address them. Yesterday I remade an acquaintance with an old film, one that is probably in my top fifty: not the sort of thing that usually appeals to nerds, but if you simply like a very good story, you can find Kind Hearts and Coronets here in its entirety. The film, while utterly ignored by the Oscars on account of being British and unsavory, brilliantly displays what a genius Alec Guinness was, and goes that first step for the uninitiated towards explaining why he detested the role of Obi-Wan Kenobi so much. If the gentle reader has already seen The Man in the White Suit, The Horse's Mouth, The Lavender Hill Mob, Last Holiday, Tunes of Glory and the Bridge on the River Kwai - along with at least ten other very worthy films - you're well aware of the man's impressive range, and why he quite probably before-the-fact viewed Kenobi as "phoning it in" for the cash. God knows why Guinness needed it at that time, but from all reports he regretted it for the rest of his life.
But then Star Wars is a piece of cinematic shit that took advantage of some new technology and an old, popular set of plot devices that have always served to amuse the groundlings, as Shakespeare called them. When I was twelve and first saw the film, I thought it was brilliant. When I was twenty and saw it again, I realized that growing up develops one's discrimination.
I say this full well knowing the number of man-boy nerds who will stamp their feet and pout and go around in another big circle about how I am full of myself and all, and don't appreciate 'fun' and blah blah blah. It is incomprehensible to many that a person simply could not like Star Wars because it is a bad movie, abounding with overused plot tropes and stock wooden characters who do not, any more, 'speak' to my view of life. To put it another way, it isn't 'fun' for me because it is terribly, awfully simple-minded. Visually it looks like a lot of people in really obvious costumes walking around on really obvious set pieces carrying bits of plastic and pointing them at each other like ten-year-old children. At ten, these things were fun of course, but I've long since come to a place where I need more than plastic toys to fire my imagination.
I'd also like to say that there's been time now to talk to the people who put forth the $100 to get a subscription to my game designs, and everyone seems very happy. I have no proof of this, of course, since this is the internet, and I'm not exposing people who don't want to be seen ... but I must comment on others who have made a great stomping, pouting show about how much money it is and what a pompous ass I am for daring to suggest that someone might spend one hundred dollars on whatever I happen to have created. This mind-boggling impossibility is without question measured against the money most people spend during a Friday night at the local bar or tavern, food and drinks included, or the thousands of people right now who are laying hundred dollar bets that a red jack and a seven will beat whatever's in the dealer's hand. Because obviously a hundred dollars is SO much money that data representing twenty years of work could never be its equal.
I don't know. The stomping and the pouting is such an important part of the internet, it's hard not to look at it once in awhile from a purely sociological point of view. A few weeks ago I called quite a number of people on this blog 'idiots,' capitalizing the letters for emphasis, which created a small trickle of other people cleverly capitalizing the word on other blogs while pointedly not using my name or defining the source. But naturally, everyone knew who was being talked about. I wonder if any of these people can understand how spectacular that is for me, to know that there are so many people who read this blog that an oblique reference to something I've written here can be ascribed and understood by others because they've read it here. Not that it makes any difference, mind, to anything except my ego. The world is the same world. The things we like are the same things. I go on making my world, my way, and other people buy it and enjoy it their way, and other people scoff and then move on with their little lives, and so on and so forth.
It is as though all of this doesn't make very much difference at all. It is as though it is all just a lot of strutting and fretting hours upon the stage, by IDIOTS, full of sound and fury ... well, you ought to know the rest of the quote. The Star Wars people can look it up on the internet.
Viewed from that angle, with little else to prop up the existence of some people, I am not surprised that blogging becomes a soul-destroying prospect, driving the blogger to despair and ultimately the decision to stop strutting and fretting altogether, and return to prospects in life that may offer gratification that is somewhat less than immediate and fleeting.
If I blogged only for the effect I could cause, I could quit now, having cheerfully proved what puppets some people are and how easy it is to get under their skin.
But that's not enough for me. That it is believed by some to be my whole purpose is not very surprising, given that people can only surmise the aspirations of others from their own limited imaginations. And given that their imaginations extend to the belief that Star Wars is a good film, I'm not surprised they miss me and my purpose by at least 12 parsecs (which is a distance, and not a measure of time).
I must explain what does make it for me. It isn't the arguments, that must be made for the sake of those who find themselves caught in so much dreck and wish for something better. It isn't the numbers on this blog, that climb steadily from month to month. It isn't the laughable attempts to evicerate me elsewhere that prove my influence. It isn't racking up another blog post here, although 755 is a nice, tidy sum to have already written.
It is, to wit, the frank creation of life and events going on over there on the other blog, the campaign the players assure me is full of fun and excitement. It is the powerful sense of achievement that comes from constructing another map, or from overcoming another obstacle in the creation of algorithms for the purpose of deepening my world, or from feeling just generally that art is in itself a marvelous means of achieving self-satisfaction.
I stop every once in awhile, upon having a really good day, and realize just how happy I am.
And running D&D is sort of the point of it all, isn't it?
Still, I have a few things on my mind and I thought I'd address them. Yesterday I remade an acquaintance with an old film, one that is probably in my top fifty: not the sort of thing that usually appeals to nerds, but if you simply like a very good story, you can find Kind Hearts and Coronets here in its entirety. The film, while utterly ignored by the Oscars on account of being British and unsavory, brilliantly displays what a genius Alec Guinness was, and goes that first step for the uninitiated towards explaining why he detested the role of Obi-Wan Kenobi so much. If the gentle reader has already seen The Man in the White Suit, The Horse's Mouth, The Lavender Hill Mob, Last Holiday, Tunes of Glory and the Bridge on the River Kwai - along with at least ten other very worthy films - you're well aware of the man's impressive range, and why he quite probably before-the-fact viewed Kenobi as "phoning it in" for the cash. God knows why Guinness needed it at that time, but from all reports he regretted it for the rest of his life.
But then Star Wars is a piece of cinematic shit that took advantage of some new technology and an old, popular set of plot devices that have always served to amuse the groundlings, as Shakespeare called them. When I was twelve and first saw the film, I thought it was brilliant. When I was twenty and saw it again, I realized that growing up develops one's discrimination.
I say this full well knowing the number of man-boy nerds who will stamp their feet and pout and go around in another big circle about how I am full of myself and all, and don't appreciate 'fun' and blah blah blah. It is incomprehensible to many that a person simply could not like Star Wars because it is a bad movie, abounding with overused plot tropes and stock wooden characters who do not, any more, 'speak' to my view of life. To put it another way, it isn't 'fun' for me because it is terribly, awfully simple-minded. Visually it looks like a lot of people in really obvious costumes walking around on really obvious set pieces carrying bits of plastic and pointing them at each other like ten-year-old children. At ten, these things were fun of course, but I've long since come to a place where I need more than plastic toys to fire my imagination.
I'd also like to say that there's been time now to talk to the people who put forth the $100 to get a subscription to my game designs, and everyone seems very happy. I have no proof of this, of course, since this is the internet, and I'm not exposing people who don't want to be seen ... but I must comment on others who have made a great stomping, pouting show about how much money it is and what a pompous ass I am for daring to suggest that someone might spend one hundred dollars on whatever I happen to have created. This mind-boggling impossibility is without question measured against the money most people spend during a Friday night at the local bar or tavern, food and drinks included, or the thousands of people right now who are laying hundred dollar bets that a red jack and a seven will beat whatever's in the dealer's hand. Because obviously a hundred dollars is SO much money that data representing twenty years of work could never be its equal.
I don't know. The stomping and the pouting is such an important part of the internet, it's hard not to look at it once in awhile from a purely sociological point of view. A few weeks ago I called quite a number of people on this blog 'idiots,' capitalizing the letters for emphasis, which created a small trickle of other people cleverly capitalizing the word on other blogs while pointedly not using my name or defining the source. But naturally, everyone knew who was being talked about. I wonder if any of these people can understand how spectacular that is for me, to know that there are so many people who read this blog that an oblique reference to something I've written here can be ascribed and understood by others because they've read it here. Not that it makes any difference, mind, to anything except my ego. The world is the same world. The things we like are the same things. I go on making my world, my way, and other people buy it and enjoy it their way, and other people scoff and then move on with their little lives, and so on and so forth.
It is as though all of this doesn't make very much difference at all. It is as though it is all just a lot of strutting and fretting hours upon the stage, by IDIOTS, full of sound and fury ... well, you ought to know the rest of the quote. The Star Wars people can look it up on the internet.
Viewed from that angle, with little else to prop up the existence of some people, I am not surprised that blogging becomes a soul-destroying prospect, driving the blogger to despair and ultimately the decision to stop strutting and fretting altogether, and return to prospects in life that may offer gratification that is somewhat less than immediate and fleeting.
If I blogged only for the effect I could cause, I could quit now, having cheerfully proved what puppets some people are and how easy it is to get under their skin.
But that's not enough for me. That it is believed by some to be my whole purpose is not very surprising, given that people can only surmise the aspirations of others from their own limited imaginations. And given that their imaginations extend to the belief that Star Wars is a good film, I'm not surprised they miss me and my purpose by at least 12 parsecs (which is a distance, and not a measure of time).
I must explain what does make it for me. It isn't the arguments, that must be made for the sake of those who find themselves caught in so much dreck and wish for something better. It isn't the numbers on this blog, that climb steadily from month to month. It isn't the laughable attempts to evicerate me elsewhere that prove my influence. It isn't racking up another blog post here, although 755 is a nice, tidy sum to have already written.
It is, to wit, the frank creation of life and events going on over there on the other blog, the campaign the players assure me is full of fun and excitement. It is the powerful sense of achievement that comes from constructing another map, or from overcoming another obstacle in the creation of algorithms for the purpose of deepening my world, or from feeling just generally that art is in itself a marvelous means of achieving self-satisfaction.
I stop every once in awhile, upon having a really good day, and realize just how happy I am.
Tuesday, November 1, 2011
Deactivating Characters
It may be that my particular technique of wringing emotions from a group of player characters may be disrupting to some player attempts at roleplaying ... and I'm not sure that's a bad thing.
I perceive that my principle role as DM is to elicit an emotional reaction with any part of the game that might be on the table at a particular time. Things that are unknown should be concerning and even frightening. Combat should be thrilling and definitely scary as the hit points flutter away. Treasure and NPC recognition should be fruitful and promising, and should make a player's chest swell. Treason should make a player angry. Trickery should obtain disbelief ... and then more anger. Conquest should bring pride and ambition. And so on.
I like to believe I manage these emotions through the little events of the game, building them a bit here or there with a casual word at first, a few descriptive phrases, an NPC with an agenda and so on. I like to believe that these things are crafted so that whatever the adopted roleplaying 'stance' of a player's character, it will be the PLAYER who responds to the taunting, the insult or the proposition that is put on the table.
If it can be understood: as DM, I am not speaking to the characters. I can't speak to the characters. I have no idea how Boffo the Monk would respond to my manipulations ... but Boffo's puppeteer is going to hear whatever I say, and if I can get under the puppeteer's skin, Boffo will do what the puppeteer wants.
That is, even if the puppeteer thinks Boffo wouldn't.
And that is the thing. The player enters the campaign with some idea in mind of what their character will be interested in, and what their character would want, or what the character wouldn't do ... but none of that really matters. The character isn't real. The character is a mutable thing that will change its spots just as fast as the player wants. And if I dangle the right carrot in front of the player, those spots are gonna change.
I've made the point in the past (no idea where, sorry) that the characters I used to run as a player were fundamentally Me. And I know there are a lot of players out there who feel that's not what roleplaying is ... but really, when you get right down to it, when a particular NPC keeps getting in your way, and spoiling everything you try, and the only way to move forward is to say to hell with the characterization you've invented - you're going to move forward.
Hasn't always been true. I've been short-circuited. I've had players accept even death before changing. But I don't see that as a virtue of roleplaying. I see it as me failing to really get the emotional response I was going for.
Performance arts are fraught with failure. Sometimes the audience doesn't applaud. Sometimes they don't laugh. But you know you're on the right track when someone who came into the theatre certain that they'd do neither finds they can't help themselves. When they aren't 'themselves,' you know you're taking names and kicking ass.
I perceive that my principle role as DM is to elicit an emotional reaction with any part of the game that might be on the table at a particular time. Things that are unknown should be concerning and even frightening. Combat should be thrilling and definitely scary as the hit points flutter away. Treasure and NPC recognition should be fruitful and promising, and should make a player's chest swell. Treason should make a player angry. Trickery should obtain disbelief ... and then more anger. Conquest should bring pride and ambition. And so on.
I like to believe I manage these emotions through the little events of the game, building them a bit here or there with a casual word at first, a few descriptive phrases, an NPC with an agenda and so on. I like to believe that these things are crafted so that whatever the adopted roleplaying 'stance' of a player's character, it will be the PLAYER who responds to the taunting, the insult or the proposition that is put on the table.
If it can be understood: as DM, I am not speaking to the characters. I can't speak to the characters. I have no idea how Boffo the Monk would respond to my manipulations ... but Boffo's puppeteer is going to hear whatever I say, and if I can get under the puppeteer's skin, Boffo will do what the puppeteer wants.
That is, even if the puppeteer thinks Boffo wouldn't.
And that is the thing. The player enters the campaign with some idea in mind of what their character will be interested in, and what their character would want, or what the character wouldn't do ... but none of that really matters. The character isn't real. The character is a mutable thing that will change its spots just as fast as the player wants. And if I dangle the right carrot in front of the player, those spots are gonna change.
I've made the point in the past (no idea where, sorry) that the characters I used to run as a player were fundamentally Me. And I know there are a lot of players out there who feel that's not what roleplaying is ... but really, when you get right down to it, when a particular NPC keeps getting in your way, and spoiling everything you try, and the only way to move forward is to say to hell with the characterization you've invented - you're going to move forward.
Hasn't always been true. I've been short-circuited. I've had players accept even death before changing. But I don't see that as a virtue of roleplaying. I see it as me failing to really get the emotional response I was going for.
Performance arts are fraught with failure. Sometimes the audience doesn't applaud. Sometimes they don't laugh. But you know you're on the right track when someone who came into the theatre certain that they'd do neither finds they can't help themselves. When they aren't 'themselves,' you know you're taking names and kicking ass.
Monday, October 31, 2011
Player vs. Player
I have been thinking lately of the old trope of players vs. players in D&D campaigns, primarily because it has emerged in a few games like an unwanted relative. I have been playing one particular campaign in which everyone is a friend for so long, I haven't had to deal with this.
I've played in, observed and heard about campaigns where this is a common theme. Online comics like to play it up for all its worth, particularly the trope about the thief slipping into the treasure room and pocketing the nicest stuff before the party sees it. You see players killing one another a la Treasure of the Sierra Madre, but its there ... and of course quite a few DMs think its hilarious.
For myself, as a player, I've always found it a little difficult to stomach. After all, I am interacting socially with a person who is either gloating or otherwise behaving like an asshole as they kill something I've worked to keep alive and healthy, and that I've grown attached to ... and I'm expected to simply consider it 'part of the game.' I'm not to consider the action boorish, or proof of a lacking character.
When I was a boy, I had a grandfather whose favorite game in the world was cribbage, and who took great glee in being able to call 'muggins' on my 10-year-old self. For those of you who may not know, in the game of cribbage, if you count your cards for less points than they're worth, and then peg the total you've counted incorrectly, your opponent can declare "muggins" and count those points themselves. Thus, if you are a ten-year-old boy, and you have not played cribbage for sixty years, and have therefore not had all this time to train yourself to be a self-serving asshole, you can expect to lose a couple of points a game to a grandfather whose belief system includes taking advantage of this difference.
My grandfather used to tell me that it would "smarten me up" to the ways of the world, clearly with the expectation that someday I would be able to skin players with less skill - or commitment to winning, I suppose - than I would eventually have under my grandfather's tutelage. It was supposed to teach me to count cards more fastidiously. What it taught me was not to play cards with my grandfather.
If today I found myself playing cribbage with someone who called 'muggins' on me, I believe my first inclination would be to punch them in the face. I wouldn't do that, of course. I haven't punched anyone in the face since grade school. But my second inclination would be to tell them what assholes they were, rise from the table, and never play cribbage with them again. Or anything else, for that matter. I don't associate with people like this.
My parents, incidentally, played cribbage all the time, and the house rule was that if a hand was counted improperly, other people helped to make sure the count was right and the game continued in a friendly, competitive manner. So I guess my grandfather's influence on his children didn't go very far.
It isn't that there aren't people playing cut-throat D&D. It's only that I would like these people to be hit by a bus or something ... if they can't learn the error of their ways, that is, and smarten up.
To discourage this behavior, I usually try to play a wide-open game ... that is, I don't often share secret information with one part of the party and intentionally keep others in the dark. I used to do this all the time - it seemed like fun, taking people out into the back to describe something only they could see, or encouraging players not to be open about their characters, or encouraging secret messages to be sent around the table. In the long run, however, all this really did was to create a level of distrust which eventually disrupted the game and drove off players.
Some gentle readers might react to this assertion with the sentiment that players who would quit a game over something like this weren't good enough to play. Or 'mature' enough. Or some other belief my grandfather would have appreciated, that 'strong' players don't crumble because their characters are killed. That is, that 'muggins' is part of the game, and if you can't play with muggins then you don't deserve to play.
I have found, generally, that without all the running around behind other people's backs, players form a camaraderie that is much, much stronger than backstabbing and player-from-player theft will allow. Games tend to improve with time, rather than fall apart. Players respect one another. Players treat each other with compassion and concern. This doesn't seem like a bad thing to me. It sounds a game that 'adults' would play. Adults who can work for long-term goals and not short-term gain.
And I'm funny. I prefer to play with adults.
I've played in, observed and heard about campaigns where this is a common theme. Online comics like to play it up for all its worth, particularly the trope about the thief slipping into the treasure room and pocketing the nicest stuff before the party sees it. You see players killing one another a la Treasure of the Sierra Madre, but its there ... and of course quite a few DMs think its hilarious.
For myself, as a player, I've always found it a little difficult to stomach. After all, I am interacting socially with a person who is either gloating or otherwise behaving like an asshole as they kill something I've worked to keep alive and healthy, and that I've grown attached to ... and I'm expected to simply consider it 'part of the game.' I'm not to consider the action boorish, or proof of a lacking character.
When I was a boy, I had a grandfather whose favorite game in the world was cribbage, and who took great glee in being able to call 'muggins' on my 10-year-old self. For those of you who may not know, in the game of cribbage, if you count your cards for less points than they're worth, and then peg the total you've counted incorrectly, your opponent can declare "muggins" and count those points themselves. Thus, if you are a ten-year-old boy, and you have not played cribbage for sixty years, and have therefore not had all this time to train yourself to be a self-serving asshole, you can expect to lose a couple of points a game to a grandfather whose belief system includes taking advantage of this difference.
My grandfather used to tell me that it would "smarten me up" to the ways of the world, clearly with the expectation that someday I would be able to skin players with less skill - or commitment to winning, I suppose - than I would eventually have under my grandfather's tutelage. It was supposed to teach me to count cards more fastidiously. What it taught me was not to play cards with my grandfather.
If today I found myself playing cribbage with someone who called 'muggins' on me, I believe my first inclination would be to punch them in the face. I wouldn't do that, of course. I haven't punched anyone in the face since grade school. But my second inclination would be to tell them what assholes they were, rise from the table, and never play cribbage with them again. Or anything else, for that matter. I don't associate with people like this.
My parents, incidentally, played cribbage all the time, and the house rule was that if a hand was counted improperly, other people helped to make sure the count was right and the game continued in a friendly, competitive manner. So I guess my grandfather's influence on his children didn't go very far.
It isn't that there aren't people playing cut-throat D&D. It's only that I would like these people to be hit by a bus or something ... if they can't learn the error of their ways, that is, and smarten up.
To discourage this behavior, I usually try to play a wide-open game ... that is, I don't often share secret information with one part of the party and intentionally keep others in the dark. I used to do this all the time - it seemed like fun, taking people out into the back to describe something only they could see, or encouraging players not to be open about their characters, or encouraging secret messages to be sent around the table. In the long run, however, all this really did was to create a level of distrust which eventually disrupted the game and drove off players.
Some gentle readers might react to this assertion with the sentiment that players who would quit a game over something like this weren't good enough to play. Or 'mature' enough. Or some other belief my grandfather would have appreciated, that 'strong' players don't crumble because their characters are killed. That is, that 'muggins' is part of the game, and if you can't play with muggins then you don't deserve to play.
I have found, generally, that without all the running around behind other people's backs, players form a camaraderie that is much, much stronger than backstabbing and player-from-player theft will allow. Games tend to improve with time, rather than fall apart. Players respect one another. Players treat each other with compassion and concern. This doesn't seem like a bad thing to me. It sounds a game that 'adults' would play. Adults who can work for long-term goals and not short-term gain.
And I'm funny. I prefer to play with adults.
Friday, October 28, 2011
Character Calculation
Let's tackle this big table. This is one that definitely needs some work by me, which I am putting off because I must tell you this table is a persnickity bitch and I don't enjoy working on it very much. Still, the results are good and I like what it does for the campaign.
Incidentally, this is called 'Chararacter Calculation' because there are files on my drive called 'Character Generation' and 'Character Background' and 'Background' and so on already. This is the last of a long line of similar attempts, and all the good names have been taken. I'm just about ready to throw out all the past work, but for some reason I keep holding onto it.
All right, here's the idea. You input the race, the class, the stats and the gender, and the table pumps out a background, a secondary skill learned from the father (and possibly the mother, too), age, weight, birthday, starting capital, your credit rating (17th century world, remember) and some special things about your character. It is all calculated on random rolls based on the player's stats, and it is all neatly meant to be packaged on the 'Display' tab so that it can be printed when the character is rolled up.
At the moment the copy you have has the Display tab updated for Strength, Intelligence and Wisdom. I am in the middle of working on Constitution, and could do it in an hour or two. Dexterity wouldn't take long after that, but at the moment Charisma is a virtual nightmare. I have been avoiding this because I know that creating a character appearance that matches the charisma is going to be just hell.
Hey, I procrastinate. I did at one time join Procrastinator's Anonymous, but for some reason I just couldn't get out to the meetings.
If you want to muck around with it, putting in some stats and hitting F9 several times, you can see the results will change fairly widely. Certain aspects, such as family, not much. I don't promise there isn't a glitch somewhere - I find them from time to time, and fix as I do. There's a lot of calculations going on to make this table.
Starting with the 'Str' tab, the first one I did, you can see it is in two parts. Part 1 covers columns A through M, and Part 2 columns O through V. The orientation is different, because I tried this first one way, and then the other. I liked the second way better, and kept that for the rest of the file; eventually I may take the time to reformat the first part of the Str tab, but for now I don't care.
Strength affects two aspects: genetic background and physicality. A d20 is rolled against strength, and the difference determines the result. This is really nothing more than making this table (or this earlier version) automatic.
What is extremely pleasant about this set up is that if something new occurs to you to add to the table, you just create another window and set up a random generator. If you look at the cells P10 through U10, you can see that I've done this, making one result occur on a roll of 1 in 6, and the other 5 in 6. Extending this with a little imagination could make hundreds of possible results for each roll, without having to write the table from scratch - making the excel file infinitely better than a stiff table.
If you don't know excel, this is going to seem like gobbledygook to you. If you're a programmer, you're going to scratch your head and wonder what the hell I was on ... since my knowledge of excel is imperfect and I've had to create workarounds that use aspects of excel that I understand. A programmer could have a field day streamlining this, I'm certain.
Nevertheless, I've tried to make a lot of determinations automatic. When you lose a hand, it determines which hand; if you have a sibling, it determines whether its a brother or a sister. One thing it does not do is determine if you're the oldest or the youngest sibling ... it could do that, but the trouble isn't worth it. If anyone cares, I can roll that out with dice.
Throughout the file, I try to use yellow highlighting to show final results. Orange highlighting is usually a temporary crucial results, light tan is for description, blue for principle random results and gray for secondary random results, green for die rolls ... but believe me I break this rule as much as I use it. I tried to include a lot of description for what this die means and that, but I'm afraid I was more interested in producing results than copying them. But if you need me to tell you what something particular means, give me the cell and the tab and I'll try to answer it.
You'll note the father's table (the 'F' tab) is a random generator for character skills. It selects from your stats the background of your father, and if you stat is less than 11 your father will begin from some other stat. If all your stats are less than 11, you won't have a profession. Your father determines your starting capital (though it is modified by certain events that might occur as a result of your intelligence and your wisdom) or your credit ... if you father is a banker you can borrow tons of money. It is possible to be nobility or royalty. That is worked out too, along with how much land you own or if you're in charge of it (you might not be the eldest sibling in the family after all, or your parents might still be alive), or how big a country your family runs. I leave which country up to the DM - not all worlds are the same.
Hitting F9 on this page will show the random descriptions change; there's quite a number of possible options, and of course more can be added.
There's a chance on the Intelligence table of having both learned a father's profession and a mother's, and so the father's table is duplicated on the 'M' tab - M for Mother - so that a completely different result can be generated.
It's possible to start with men-at-arms, so these are generated on the 'Men-at-Arms' table.
If you constitution is low, or through a bad roll, you could have between a mild and a severe chronic disease ... this is determined on the 'Conditions' table. These include blindness and deafness, but those aren't likely. Color confusion or a low tolerance for spirits is more probable. Conditions can modify your height and weight, which are themselves calculated on the 'Biology' tab.
Here is a long bit of calculations that determines the height and weight for your race and your gender, according to the tables in the DMG - but again, made automatic. It adjusts your height/weight for other variables in the table. Columns AR through BB calculate your age, and also your birthday ... with a rejoiner that if you're born on February 29, that's the birthday that counts. I could have made a lot of programming to make this automatic, but it struck me as a huge pain in the neck, for something that would happen so rarely, so I didn't bother.
What is really a pain about this table is that something on this tab affects something on that tab, and that each modifier requires more programming and more fixing and so on, with all the inter-relationships piling up and getting difficult in the long run. But then, that's what makes the results interesting, as they actually have something to do with one another, and are not simply random collections of tables giving unrelated results. Everything is hinged to your character's base stats, race, gender and class, so things tend to group together to form logical characters.
But I don't pity anyone trying to go through this and decipher it. You do so at your peril. If you intend to make changes, I would suggest saving two copies, so you can change one and refer to the other.
Meanwhile, I'll push myself to keep working on this and getting it done sometime ... soon?
Incidentally, this is called 'Chararacter Calculation' because there are files on my drive called 'Character Generation' and 'Character Background' and 'Background' and so on already. This is the last of a long line of similar attempts, and all the good names have been taken. I'm just about ready to throw out all the past work, but for some reason I keep holding onto it.
All right, here's the idea. You input the race, the class, the stats and the gender, and the table pumps out a background, a secondary skill learned from the father (and possibly the mother, too), age, weight, birthday, starting capital, your credit rating (17th century world, remember) and some special things about your character. It is all calculated on random rolls based on the player's stats, and it is all neatly meant to be packaged on the 'Display' tab so that it can be printed when the character is rolled up.
At the moment the copy you have has the Display tab updated for Strength, Intelligence and Wisdom. I am in the middle of working on Constitution, and could do it in an hour or two. Dexterity wouldn't take long after that, but at the moment Charisma is a virtual nightmare. I have been avoiding this because I know that creating a character appearance that matches the charisma is going to be just hell.
Hey, I procrastinate. I did at one time join Procrastinator's Anonymous, but for some reason I just couldn't get out to the meetings.
If you want to muck around with it, putting in some stats and hitting F9 several times, you can see the results will change fairly widely. Certain aspects, such as family, not much. I don't promise there isn't a glitch somewhere - I find them from time to time, and fix as I do. There's a lot of calculations going on to make this table.
Starting with the 'Str' tab, the first one I did, you can see it is in two parts. Part 1 covers columns A through M, and Part 2 columns O through V. The orientation is different, because I tried this first one way, and then the other. I liked the second way better, and kept that for the rest of the file; eventually I may take the time to reformat the first part of the Str tab, but for now I don't care.
Strength affects two aspects: genetic background and physicality. A d20 is rolled against strength, and the difference determines the result. This is really nothing more than making this table (or this earlier version) automatic.
What is extremely pleasant about this set up is that if something new occurs to you to add to the table, you just create another window and set up a random generator. If you look at the cells P10 through U10, you can see that I've done this, making one result occur on a roll of 1 in 6, and the other 5 in 6. Extending this with a little imagination could make hundreds of possible results for each roll, without having to write the table from scratch - making the excel file infinitely better than a stiff table.
If you don't know excel, this is going to seem like gobbledygook to you. If you're a programmer, you're going to scratch your head and wonder what the hell I was on ... since my knowledge of excel is imperfect and I've had to create workarounds that use aspects of excel that I understand. A programmer could have a field day streamlining this, I'm certain.
Nevertheless, I've tried to make a lot of determinations automatic. When you lose a hand, it determines which hand; if you have a sibling, it determines whether its a brother or a sister. One thing it does not do is determine if you're the oldest or the youngest sibling ... it could do that, but the trouble isn't worth it. If anyone cares, I can roll that out with dice.
Throughout the file, I try to use yellow highlighting to show final results. Orange highlighting is usually a temporary crucial results, light tan is for description, blue for principle random results and gray for secondary random results, green for die rolls ... but believe me I break this rule as much as I use it. I tried to include a lot of description for what this die means and that, but I'm afraid I was more interested in producing results than copying them. But if you need me to tell you what something particular means, give me the cell and the tab and I'll try to answer it.
You'll note the father's table (the 'F' tab) is a random generator for character skills. It selects from your stats the background of your father, and if you stat is less than 11 your father will begin from some other stat. If all your stats are less than 11, you won't have a profession. Your father determines your starting capital (though it is modified by certain events that might occur as a result of your intelligence and your wisdom) or your credit ... if you father is a banker you can borrow tons of money. It is possible to be nobility or royalty. That is worked out too, along with how much land you own or if you're in charge of it (you might not be the eldest sibling in the family after all, or your parents might still be alive), or how big a country your family runs. I leave which country up to the DM - not all worlds are the same.
Hitting F9 on this page will show the random descriptions change; there's quite a number of possible options, and of course more can be added.
There's a chance on the Intelligence table of having both learned a father's profession and a mother's, and so the father's table is duplicated on the 'M' tab - M for Mother - so that a completely different result can be generated.
It's possible to start with men-at-arms, so these are generated on the 'Men-at-Arms' table.
If you constitution is low, or through a bad roll, you could have between a mild and a severe chronic disease ... this is determined on the 'Conditions' table. These include blindness and deafness, but those aren't likely. Color confusion or a low tolerance for spirits is more probable. Conditions can modify your height and weight, which are themselves calculated on the 'Biology' tab.
Here is a long bit of calculations that determines the height and weight for your race and your gender, according to the tables in the DMG - but again, made automatic. It adjusts your height/weight for other variables in the table. Columns AR through BB calculate your age, and also your birthday ... with a rejoiner that if you're born on February 29, that's the birthday that counts. I could have made a lot of programming to make this automatic, but it struck me as a huge pain in the neck, for something that would happen so rarely, so I didn't bother.
What is really a pain about this table is that something on this tab affects something on that tab, and that each modifier requires more programming and more fixing and so on, with all the inter-relationships piling up and getting difficult in the long run. But then, that's what makes the results interesting, as they actually have something to do with one another, and are not simply random collections of tables giving unrelated results. Everything is hinged to your character's base stats, race, gender and class, so things tend to group together to form logical characters.
But I don't pity anyone trying to go through this and decipher it. You do so at your peril. If you intend to make changes, I would suggest saving two copies, so you can change one and refer to the other.
Meanwhile, I'll push myself to keep working on this and getting it done sometime ... soon?
Thursday, October 27, 2011
Map Files
I must admit - since I knew it was going to be easy to send the material out, and that size wasn't an issue, I grabbed the whole map file as it was and made it available. Subscribers will take note there's a lot of junk in there, maps that should have been deleted, or maps that are duplicates because I intended eventually to change them to some new format (climate or otherwise). And I must also confess that when I look at these files, I see a lot of work I haven't done yet, and that makes me feel lazy.
But on the other hand, you can see how not everything I put together looks 100%, and that the fabrication of junk goes hand in hand with the fabrication of good work. That's a good thing.
Bypassing the 'Maps' folder, which is the work in the last stages, I ask the reader to look at the 'Map Rings' folder first. These many files represent the composite collection of the data on this website, which you can look over to see how the data is arranged there. Fallingrain.com is in general use by Wikipedia and other sites, and is a marvelous resource for simple and immediate information for any place in the world. That's how I stumbled across it, looking for elevation numbers.
The 'Map Rings' files, then, gives the relative elevation for every hex in the world, my having divided the hexes up according to this scheme here, which itself includes links to earlier posts on the subject. Hexes appear either white or grey, for no purpose than contrasting one ring on the documents from another, or in yellow on black for hexes that have been mapped already. This is an extremely useful check on the maps, to make sure that the hexes properly line up ... and it is a constant resource that I use while mapping to make sure I am producing accurate results. It is also helpful in the 'skewing' of the map to fit the projection effected by hexing the earth and flattening it, the reason why my maps don't look like those out of ye common Atlas. They do have a bit of medieval feel in the coastlines, however.
There's tons and tons of data there. Two things: you can find the equator on the file marked '301-320 4sep07 Done' ... its the centre tab. Also, for some reason a chunk of the western hemisphere was deleted (or failed to save back in 2007), so that rings 281-300 are missing it. I have the file elsewhere in the process of being corrected ... it isn't super important, however, so I just sort of work at it once in awhile. You can see from the dates on the files that I appear to have worked on creating this between Nov 2007 and October 2008. Those are just the latest file dates. In actual fact, the real mapping process began in 2005. It really took me three and a half years to gather the information and finish making this file. But no big deal.
Before I can create a map, however, I need to know what cities will be on it, who will control those cities in 1650 and how big those cities will be. Thus I research cities and towns shown on the maps of my olde, friendly encyclopedia (one must limit the work to some source, I'm not researching every village in the world!). The 'France Cities Workbook' is an example of my research - I am working on France to map that part of the world next. I haven't copied all the cities out of my encyclopedia yet ... only 194 of them, which would be the southern third of that country. This, too, is a task I only work at in bits; it can be quite dull to look up town after town, only to find out when it was founded and who controlled it and how many times it was burned or suffered from an illness or destroyed completely. But it does help me understand these regions more in depth as I read and read. Most of the main research, I admit, comes from wikipedia - quick search and extensive information on small, nothing places is very useful.
This information gets put together into a file like the 'Cities 22oct11' you have there. It too has little bits of floating junk on some of the tabs, such as a bit about Siberia, China, 'The Other India' (which means bits of India I actually need to make sure I've included - I think I have) and so on. The 'Compiled' tab is a mostly complete list of the cities, when they were founded (in many cases estimated), how big they are ... all the things that I put under the wikipedia months ago. This is collected together into the 'New Provinces' tab, (there used to be an old provinces tab, but its deleted now, and I never get around to changing these names), and the 'Kingdoms' tab. On the latter, you can see combined information for the population of the world at the point of latest update, and partial data on the total hexes which have been mapped for their vegetation. Again, I have so much of the world to work on.
The little box in green shows I've mapped the vegetation for just over 4 million square miles. Only 47 million square miles to go.
I have actually mapped a great deal more of the world, but I haven't determined its vegetation, and until I do that I don't record the actual size. It's just a little quibble for me - but I can see the size of a region just by looking at the map, can't I?
So, at present, there are 117 independent entities, the largest of which in population is the Moghul Empire (61 million people), mostly because it rules the heavily populated India. The Ottoman Empire comes in with nearly 30 million, and after that the Holy Roman Empire totals 14.5 million (which includes a lot of semi-independent entities). Europe has a great many people in it, but they are split and separated and usually at war with one another. The total population at present is 188 million ... which you will take note differs from the 115 million indicated on the Sources table. I added India to this, you understand. The numbers will go up again when I add the rest of Asia, Europe, Africa and all of the New World. I am estimating a world-wide total - now - of about 350 million, but that may be conservative.
This leaves the 'Map' Folder, which I'm going to cover quickly. Most of it is empty or junk, experiments or otherwise, but there are two folders worth looking at. The first would be 'New Hexes', which contains the elevation maps, and 'Terrain Maps' which includes all the vegetation maps (lord know why it's called 'terrain' ... don't worry about it). These you definitely want to look at. You can find a number of different keys for the meanings on the vegetation maps. Most of them are false, old, or flotsam before fixing them later. The one you should trust is found on the 'Ter D 06 - North Caspian' map. It is the one I think is most up to date.
Feel free to ask questions here or on email.
But on the other hand, you can see how not everything I put together looks 100%, and that the fabrication of junk goes hand in hand with the fabrication of good work. That's a good thing.
Bypassing the 'Maps' folder, which is the work in the last stages, I ask the reader to look at the 'Map Rings' folder first. These many files represent the composite collection of the data on this website, which you can look over to see how the data is arranged there. Fallingrain.com is in general use by Wikipedia and other sites, and is a marvelous resource for simple and immediate information for any place in the world. That's how I stumbled across it, looking for elevation numbers.
The 'Map Rings' files, then, gives the relative elevation for every hex in the world, my having divided the hexes up according to this scheme here, which itself includes links to earlier posts on the subject. Hexes appear either white or grey, for no purpose than contrasting one ring on the documents from another, or in yellow on black for hexes that have been mapped already. This is an extremely useful check on the maps, to make sure that the hexes properly line up ... and it is a constant resource that I use while mapping to make sure I am producing accurate results. It is also helpful in the 'skewing' of the map to fit the projection effected by hexing the earth and flattening it, the reason why my maps don't look like those out of ye common Atlas. They do have a bit of medieval feel in the coastlines, however.
There's tons and tons of data there. Two things: you can find the equator on the file marked '301-320 4sep07 Done' ... its the centre tab. Also, for some reason a chunk of the western hemisphere was deleted (or failed to save back in 2007), so that rings 281-300 are missing it. I have the file elsewhere in the process of being corrected ... it isn't super important, however, so I just sort of work at it once in awhile. You can see from the dates on the files that I appear to have worked on creating this between Nov 2007 and October 2008. Those are just the latest file dates. In actual fact, the real mapping process began in 2005. It really took me three and a half years to gather the information and finish making this file. But no big deal.
Before I can create a map, however, I need to know what cities will be on it, who will control those cities in 1650 and how big those cities will be. Thus I research cities and towns shown on the maps of my olde, friendly encyclopedia (one must limit the work to some source, I'm not researching every village in the world!). The 'France Cities Workbook' is an example of my research - I am working on France to map that part of the world next. I haven't copied all the cities out of my encyclopedia yet ... only 194 of them, which would be the southern third of that country. This, too, is a task I only work at in bits; it can be quite dull to look up town after town, only to find out when it was founded and who controlled it and how many times it was burned or suffered from an illness or destroyed completely. But it does help me understand these regions more in depth as I read and read. Most of the main research, I admit, comes from wikipedia - quick search and extensive information on small, nothing places is very useful.
This information gets put together into a file like the 'Cities 22oct11' you have there. It too has little bits of floating junk on some of the tabs, such as a bit about Siberia, China, 'The Other India' (which means bits of India I actually need to make sure I've included - I think I have) and so on. The 'Compiled' tab is a mostly complete list of the cities, when they were founded (in many cases estimated), how big they are ... all the things that I put under the wikipedia months ago. This is collected together into the 'New Provinces' tab, (there used to be an old provinces tab, but its deleted now, and I never get around to changing these names), and the 'Kingdoms' tab. On the latter, you can see combined information for the population of the world at the point of latest update, and partial data on the total hexes which have been mapped for their vegetation. Again, I have so much of the world to work on.
The little box in green shows I've mapped the vegetation for just over 4 million square miles. Only 47 million square miles to go.
I have actually mapped a great deal more of the world, but I haven't determined its vegetation, and until I do that I don't record the actual size. It's just a little quibble for me - but I can see the size of a region just by looking at the map, can't I?
So, at present, there are 117 independent entities, the largest of which in population is the Moghul Empire (61 million people), mostly because it rules the heavily populated India. The Ottoman Empire comes in with nearly 30 million, and after that the Holy Roman Empire totals 14.5 million (which includes a lot of semi-independent entities). Europe has a great many people in it, but they are split and separated and usually at war with one another. The total population at present is 188 million ... which you will take note differs from the 115 million indicated on the Sources table. I added India to this, you understand. The numbers will go up again when I add the rest of Asia, Europe, Africa and all of the New World. I am estimating a world-wide total - now - of about 350 million, but that may be conservative.
This leaves the 'Map' Folder, which I'm going to cover quickly. Most of it is empty or junk, experiments or otherwise, but there are two folders worth looking at. The first would be 'New Hexes', which contains the elevation maps, and 'Terrain Maps' which includes all the vegetation maps (lord know why it's called 'terrain' ... don't worry about it). These you definitely want to look at. You can find a number of different keys for the meanings on the vegetation maps. Most of them are false, old, or flotsam before fixing them later. The one you should trust is found on the 'Ter D 06 - North Caspian' map. It is the one I think is most up to date.
Feel free to ask questions here or on email.
Wednesday, October 26, 2011
Prices Template - Part D - End Goods & Market Page
Now we can go to the 'End Goods' section. Here we have the page where the actual items are calculated. The principle idea is that items have a given weight and quality of workmanship, and that these are multiplied against the value created on the 'Raw Material Cost' page.
For example, we've determined that 'aloe' has a price, that being (in Astrakhan) 100.16 c.p. per oz. (line 6, column C & D). The description of the item describes it as 'aloe vera' and the fact that it is '4 dozes contained in vial' and that its purpose is 'protects from the sun.' A vial is 4 oz., so column I indicates the size of the vial. There's a 10% increase in the cost for the trouble of putting the raw material in a vial. That would make the value of the aloe at 100.16 x 4 x 1.1 = 441 c.p. ... except it's not. As you can plainly see, the cost is given as 550 c.p. The reason for this is that the vial itself costs, and that cost is worked out on the 'Pre-Goods' tab. There, we see 'vial, glass, 4 oz. capacity, 1" diam., 5" high' in the 'Containers' section. You will notice that the price for this object is slightly higher than buying the glass vial alone (you can find it on line 522 of the 'End Goods' tab), and this is due also to the fact that the vial on the 'Pre-Goods' tab includes the cost of filling it, as opposed to the cost of merely buying it.
Believe me, this would all be hopelessly complex if it wasn't for the fact that when the calculation is put into the system ONCE, it is there forever and doesn't need to be worked out again.
Thus the aloe and the container together are 550 c.p. (or some other amount in some other market). Most of the time players don't think about the fact that the oil or the holy water or the wine or whatever else they buy fits into containers that apparently get thrown away once they've been used. Granted, a lot of them get broken, but when was the last time a player said he or she broke a wine bottle after drinking the wine?
550 c.p. is obviously an inconvenient number for use, so the table automatically converts this into silver or gold, rounding the number accordingly. Typically, if it is 24 c.p. or less, I record the price as copper, and if it is 384 c.p. or less, I record it as s.p. There's 12 c.p. per silver, so 384 c.p. is 32 s.p. There are 16 s.p. per gold piece in my world, so 32 s.p. is 2 g.p. ... and therefore any price less than 2 g.p. is recorded as either silver or copper. Anything more than 2 g.p. is rounded to the nearest gold piece, even if that isn't quite accurate. 550 c.p. is 2 g.p., 13 s.p. and 10 c.p., but giving prices like that would be inconvenient and would probably drive my players crazy. So I round them off and everyone is generally content with that.
If someone wanted to buy bulk goods for trade, and wanted to haggle, I suppose an exact price could be quoted ... though the exact price might actually be higher than the gold indicated.
Thereafter you see the venue, and then the weight of the items. The weight of the vial is included in the weight of the aloe in the example above, so the total weight is 5.3 oz.
Now it gets complicated.
To work out the shop selling prices, we go back to column E & F. Column E, 'Avails,' gives the total references for the item type, obtained from the 'References' tab (you see how this all pulls together). Column F generates a number between 0 and 0.25, so that if the number of references is higher than that, availability is 100%. On the other hand, you can see that aloe has an availability of 0.013, so there's only a 13 in 250 chance that aloe will be present on the seller's table.
If an item is made of more than one thing, such as a metal axe with a wooden handle, I usually set the avails to whatever is the most necessary material to make the object (or the rarest material, since this is the choke point). I'd set the material for a metal axe with a handle as the references for neither wood nor metals, but for 'tools,' which I have a reference for. That gives me a simple measure. You can see other decisions I've made throughout the table - some you may agree with, or not - but you can change them to suit yourself.
Looking at column S, then, this is merely a calculation for determining the number available, multiplied against a random number (column T), all based on the cost of the items. Large items that are expensive occur in smaller supply than smaller, cheaper items ... and may not be available at all, even if the avails indicate items of that variety are there. For example, you may be able to find various furniture, but that doesn't mean you can find an intricately carved four-poster bed. It depends on how available it is ... or how far column E is below column F.
The item description is repeated for easy importation to the next table, along with the price, coin, weight and then the total number available.
Columns AC to AJ then does the same in reverse. The cost of the item and its availability determines how many the shop vendor will buy from the player, and for how much. Then columns AL to AS determines it all again, for selling to passers by (or for selling in a village or on the road, anywhere that there isn't a market present).
I was reworking this table through the summer, so you should be aware that everything after shipbuilder (lines 1170 and down) haven't been upgraded to the present detail (the 'Pre-Goods' table hasn't been incorporated yet, along with other inconsistencies that I didn't get to. I simply got tired of working on goods, as it is exhausting and picky and takes a great deal of time. I did get more than a 1100 objects done before quitting, right? I'll pick this up again sometime, I promise. Only 450+ to go.
Also, please note that Jeweller is a mess and has been put on hold for the moment. This is a more pressing issue, and really needs some solid attention. I'd like to work on this before Christmas, but I'll probably work on the Character Generation Table first.
Finally, a quick word about the 'Market Page' tab. This is obviously the only page which the player's sees. I usually copy and paste this first as values on another page, then paste it as format, so there are no calculations remaining. Takes just a few seconds. Then I can show it to the players.
So, to recap: if you want to make a new market, there's the two actions on the Selected page, which ends with pasting the data on the 'Input Data' page on the Prices Template. Then you can move immediately to the Market Page, copy that and post the new prices for the players.
Like I said, a pistol. The actual calculation and presentation for the players doesn't slow the game down at all. You generate a new table and provide it. It takes new players a long time to go through 1,600 buyable items, but I've found with time players get quite used to searching through and finding what they want. Mostly that works because I've anticipated a character's need, and most things are certain to be there - and can be searched for with Ctrl F.
I once had it set up so that changing one thing on the Selected table changed everything else automatically, but this created huge problems in excel, as I always find when there are multiple tables open or not open. It is an issue with excel. I would have all of this together on one single page, except that the computer I have still can't handle the capacity and the number of calculations slows everything down. But tech is moving forward, so I suppose with my next computer I'll be able to convert these together ... and one day with the sources table also.
The rest is all junk. Make what you will of it. For the present, that's the last trading file. From here we move onto mapmaking.
For example, we've determined that 'aloe' has a price, that being (in Astrakhan) 100.16 c.p. per oz. (line 6, column C & D). The description of the item describes it as 'aloe vera' and the fact that it is '4 dozes contained in vial' and that its purpose is 'protects from the sun.' A vial is 4 oz., so column I indicates the size of the vial. There's a 10% increase in the cost for the trouble of putting the raw material in a vial. That would make the value of the aloe at 100.16 x 4 x 1.1 = 441 c.p. ... except it's not. As you can plainly see, the cost is given as 550 c.p. The reason for this is that the vial itself costs, and that cost is worked out on the 'Pre-Goods' tab. There, we see 'vial, glass, 4 oz. capacity, 1" diam., 5" high' in the 'Containers' section. You will notice that the price for this object is slightly higher than buying the glass vial alone (you can find it on line 522 of the 'End Goods' tab), and this is due also to the fact that the vial on the 'Pre-Goods' tab includes the cost of filling it, as opposed to the cost of merely buying it.
Believe me, this would all be hopelessly complex if it wasn't for the fact that when the calculation is put into the system ONCE, it is there forever and doesn't need to be worked out again.
Thus the aloe and the container together are 550 c.p. (or some other amount in some other market). Most of the time players don't think about the fact that the oil or the holy water or the wine or whatever else they buy fits into containers that apparently get thrown away once they've been used. Granted, a lot of them get broken, but when was the last time a player said he or she broke a wine bottle after drinking the wine?
550 c.p. is obviously an inconvenient number for use, so the table automatically converts this into silver or gold, rounding the number accordingly. Typically, if it is 24 c.p. or less, I record the price as copper, and if it is 384 c.p. or less, I record it as s.p. There's 12 c.p. per silver, so 384 c.p. is 32 s.p. There are 16 s.p. per gold piece in my world, so 32 s.p. is 2 g.p. ... and therefore any price less than 2 g.p. is recorded as either silver or copper. Anything more than 2 g.p. is rounded to the nearest gold piece, even if that isn't quite accurate. 550 c.p. is 2 g.p., 13 s.p. and 10 c.p., but giving prices like that would be inconvenient and would probably drive my players crazy. So I round them off and everyone is generally content with that.
If someone wanted to buy bulk goods for trade, and wanted to haggle, I suppose an exact price could be quoted ... though the exact price might actually be higher than the gold indicated.
Thereafter you see the venue, and then the weight of the items. The weight of the vial is included in the weight of the aloe in the example above, so the total weight is 5.3 oz.
Now it gets complicated.
To work out the shop selling prices, we go back to column E & F. Column E, 'Avails,' gives the total references for the item type, obtained from the 'References' tab (you see how this all pulls together). Column F generates a number between 0 and 0.25, so that if the number of references is higher than that, availability is 100%. On the other hand, you can see that aloe has an availability of 0.013, so there's only a 13 in 250 chance that aloe will be present on the seller's table.
If an item is made of more than one thing, such as a metal axe with a wooden handle, I usually set the avails to whatever is the most necessary material to make the object (or the rarest material, since this is the choke point). I'd set the material for a metal axe with a handle as the references for neither wood nor metals, but for 'tools,' which I have a reference for. That gives me a simple measure. You can see other decisions I've made throughout the table - some you may agree with, or not - but you can change them to suit yourself.
Looking at column S, then, this is merely a calculation for determining the number available, multiplied against a random number (column T), all based on the cost of the items. Large items that are expensive occur in smaller supply than smaller, cheaper items ... and may not be available at all, even if the avails indicate items of that variety are there. For example, you may be able to find various furniture, but that doesn't mean you can find an intricately carved four-poster bed. It depends on how available it is ... or how far column E is below column F.
The item description is repeated for easy importation to the next table, along with the price, coin, weight and then the total number available.
Columns AC to AJ then does the same in reverse. The cost of the item and its availability determines how many the shop vendor will buy from the player, and for how much. Then columns AL to AS determines it all again, for selling to passers by (or for selling in a village or on the road, anywhere that there isn't a market present).
I was reworking this table through the summer, so you should be aware that everything after shipbuilder (lines 1170 and down) haven't been upgraded to the present detail (the 'Pre-Goods' table hasn't been incorporated yet, along with other inconsistencies that I didn't get to. I simply got tired of working on goods, as it is exhausting and picky and takes a great deal of time. I did get more than a 1100 objects done before quitting, right? I'll pick this up again sometime, I promise. Only 450+ to go.
Also, please note that Jeweller is a mess and has been put on hold for the moment. This is a more pressing issue, and really needs some solid attention. I'd like to work on this before Christmas, but I'll probably work on the Character Generation Table first.
Finally, a quick word about the 'Market Page' tab. This is obviously the only page which the player's sees. I usually copy and paste this first as values on another page, then paste it as format, so there are no calculations remaining. Takes just a few seconds. Then I can show it to the players.
So, to recap: if you want to make a new market, there's the two actions on the Selected page, which ends with pasting the data on the 'Input Data' page on the Prices Template. Then you can move immediately to the Market Page, copy that and post the new prices for the players.
Like I said, a pistol. The actual calculation and presentation for the players doesn't slow the game down at all. You generate a new table and provide it. It takes new players a long time to go through 1,600 buyable items, but I've found with time players get quite used to searching through and finding what they want. Mostly that works because I've anticipated a character's need, and most things are certain to be there - and can be searched for with Ctrl F.
I once had it set up so that changing one thing on the Selected table changed everything else automatically, but this created huge problems in excel, as I always find when there are multiple tables open or not open. It is an issue with excel. I would have all of this together on one single page, except that the computer I have still can't handle the capacity and the number of calculations slows everything down. But tech is moving forward, so I suppose with my next computer I'll be able to convert these together ... and one day with the sources table also.
The rest is all junk. Make what you will of it. For the present, that's the last trading file. From here we move onto mapmaking.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
