Climbing's a Bitch

For those persons exploring the use of my sage abilities, who may also use encumbrance rules, just recently I've thrown a nasty curve ball into dungeon adventures and hauling treasure.

These are my scrambling rules:

The page explains it, but doesn't say that I'm imposing an arbitrary limit on three sorts of general movement based on the slope of ground involved.  For the present — and this may need adjustment at some point — I'm imposing no penalties on movement over ground that has less than a 30° slope.  There's no rule at all for any kind of slope in the original D&D rules, so I think this is safe.  I'm saying that any slope between 30 to 60° is very moderately hazardous, and that it takes training to move over it easily.  It's not said above, but slopes above 60° fall into the as-yet unwritten rules surrounding mountain climbing.

I've tried a couple of times to write mountain climbing rules, but remember I'm trying to make rules that have a bare minimum of die rolls, so the trouble has been to define the difference between a skilled person climbing a mountain with the reassurance of not falling, and situations where falling is distinctly possible, for anyone, regardless of skill.  I'm not a mountain climber; mountain climbers do not, unfortunately, describe their skill-set like a game metric.  Thus for the present, on that score, I'm stumped.  But I haven't tried it yet with chat, so we'll see sometime.  Not a rush.

Scrambling I've done.  Lots of it.  Not lately, granted, but I've climbed hundreds of yards of scree, roamed the inside of ice caves not under maintenance by a tourist department and maneouvred over bare rock between the 50 and 60° range.  It is very hard for some people and not to be treated lightly, though of course it ought to be doable for player characters, even mages and bards.

It's important to remember that all persons in the game world would be doing it without stippled shoes or crampons, without nylon ropes or straps, without a steel peg hard enough that it can be pounded straight into rock and so on.  This doesn't make scrambling impossible, but certainly it slows down the effort, since hurrying in the kind of boots that existed in the 16th century would have torn them to shreds in less than an hour.  We can't climb a scree slope in stockings, can we?

The speeds on the sage ability page are intended to reflect that.  An unskilled climber in poor shoes takes a 12-second combat round to move five feet up a 30 to 60° slope, because the shoes have to be protected.  Right off, that's a damn slow speed to move if there are a half dozen goblin archers 20 hexes upslope, who can see climbers every time they move out from behind a rock.

A good scrambler, on the other hand, might hurry from rock to rock well enough to get shot at less, while closing faster with the goblins.  Of course, we can't be sure the scrambler's strong enough to take them all on, alone.

That's not the cruel bit, however.  The cruel bit's the encumbrance.

My encumbrance system is highly individual to the character.  It's explained on the wiki (see link above), so I'll make this brief.

Let's say you weigh 231 lbs. and you have a strength of 15.  I've constructed a table on excel that takes these details to determine how much you can carry before losing movement, which is measured in "action points" (AP).   Most humanoids have 5 of these.  Every action your character can perform is measured in how many AP it takes to perform it.

The table shown indicates that your character can carry up to 44 lbs. and experience no loss in AP.  At 45 lbs., and anything up to 89, the adjustment is -1 AP; or, rather, that you have 4 AP.  Look at this short paragraph under "climbing speed" for scrambling:

"This [movement] assumes an encumbrance that allows the character a normal movement rate of 4 AP per round. Should the character's movement be 3 AP per round, this climbing speed is halved. An unskilled character carrying enough equipment to lower their movement to 2 AP per round could not climb slopes of this nature."

Therefore, as a robust, fairly strong character, who's also unskilled in scrambling, you can only climb or descend at even a slow pace as you don't carry more than 89 lbs. on your character — and trust me, after armour, weapons, gear and clothing, that's not so much weight to carry.  If you lower your normal movement rate to -2 AP on the chart above, or "3 AP," carrying a weight up to 134 lbs., you move at half speed.  One hex every two rounds climbing, 2 hexes every three rounds descending.  Carrying even a moderate sack of newly acquired gold coins, it's going to take you a long time to reach the bottom.

There's no way at all that you can hoist some massive chest on your back and head off.

And it's much, much worse for elves and other small characters.  This second table shows the encumbrance penalties for an elf with a 15 strength and a weight of 100 lbs.  The table, understand, works as a ratio of your strength measured against your weight.  An elf can't carry as much as a great big human.  It's one of the benefits there is in my game to being human.  You may not get a +1 to hit with sword and bow, but you can definitely carry extra weapons.

This elf-version of the table is brutal.  Remember that while an elf's armour has less body to cover, the weapons are still the same weight, and so are the coins, the rope, the backpack that holds the same amount and so on.  If you want your elf to be well-equipped when you get to the dungeon, all the way up there on the mountainside, you'd better hire a porter to carry it for you, so you can dress in it when you get there.

And this is what I like.  Players would no doubt carp and moan about the "unfairness" of it all, or how it "kills" gaming and what not, but for me it says that the goblins are pretty smart to choose a cave that's 2200 ft. above the valley floor.  If a party wants to kill those smart goblins, they better be smart too.

This is how tropes get broken in D&D.  It's how we throw a curve ball at the player who's all, "Oh well, climb to the dungeon, same-ol, same-ol."

I haven't thrown this at my own players yet.  I just know they're not going to like it.

_____

If you wish to comment, please write questions, ideas or opinions to alexiss1@telus.net and they will be posted on Saturdays.  Feel free to introduce new subjects or present your own work. 

If you wish to make a donation to Patreon, it will be greatly appreciated and help with costs for illustrating the Streetvendor's Guide.